World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Jewish campus life at a ‘crossing point’ as students weigh antisemitism risks, new report shows
A new report from the advocacy group Alums for Campus Fairness (ACF) finds that US university leadership's response to campus tensions is decisive in whether Jewish students feel safe or targeted, with support or hostility varying sharply between institutions. The 2025-26 Campus Climate Brief ranks 14 campuses as "most concerning" and 17 as "most supportive" for Jewish students across 17 states, arguing that colleges willing to actively back Jewish and Zionist students tend to see thriving, welcoming communities, while others have allowed anti-Zionist sentiment to take hold institutionally.
ACF assessed schools against five criteria: recorded incidents, institutional response to antisemitism, anti-Israel organising, the state of Jewish campus life, and the legal and structural environment. Among the ten campuses named most concerning were Middlebury College, The New School, DePaul University, Smith College, Sarah Lawrence College, San Francisco State University, the University of Texas at Dallas, UC Berkeley, Oberlin College and George Mason University, with further "honourable mentions" including the City University of New York system and the University of Washington. Cited incidents included antisemitic graffiti and "wanted" posters targeting Jewish regents at Berkeley, a vigil advertised by a Students for Justice in Palestine chapter honouring a Hamas leader, and a Justice Department lawsuit against Berkeley over an alleged hostile environment; San Francisco State disputed its inclusion, citing its Hillel partnership and antisemitism-prevention programme.
In short
- ACF report ranks US campuses on Jewish student safety and support.
- Ten schools, including Berkeley and Middlebury, named most concerning.
- Report says leadership response, not tension itself, shapes campus climate.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
ACF’s findings support the view that university leaders have a duty to respond clearly to antisemitic incidents and ensure Jewish students can participate in campus life without intimidation. Where leaders fail to address threats, harassment or exclusion, students may reasonably feel that their safety and equal treatment are not being taken seriously.
The case against
The report’s rankings and conclusions reflect an advocacy group’s chosen criteria, so they may not capture the full range of campus experiences or distinguish antisemitism from forceful criticism of Israel. Universities may also argue that they must protect political expression while responding to specific misconduct, and that judging an institution from selected incidents risks overlooking its broader efforts and the views of Jewish students who feel supported.
Explained simply
US universities have Jewish students and student groups, alongside organisations that campaign over Israel and the Palestinians. Disagreement about Israel can become a campus issue when students report harassment or exclusion because they are Jewish, or when universities face questions about how to protect free expression while addressing antisemitism.
Alums for Campus Fairness (ACF) is an advocacy group that assessed 2025–26 campus conditions using reported incidents, university responses, organising, Jewish campus life and legal factors. Its report places some universities among those it considers most concerning and others among the most supportive; the rankings reflect ACF’s assessment, and at least one named university has disputed its inclusion. The debate matters because universities’ policies and responses can shape students’ safety and ability to take part in campus life.
Americas Climate Science World