Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Toronto Awards Analysis: ‘I Play Rocky’ Channels Namesake, Could Follow in Its Oscar Footsteps
Peter Farrelly's new film "I Play Rocky", about the origins of Sylvester Stallone's 1976 boxing classic Rocky, premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival to a divided critical response but an enthusiastic audience reaction, including mid-film applause and a lengthy standing ovation. The Hollywood Reporter suggests the film could echo the awards trajectory of both Rocky itself, which won the best picture Oscar in 1977, and Farrelly's earlier TIFF hit "Green Book", which also won best picture after a similarly polarised but crowd-pleasing debut.
The film stars 27-year-old Anthony Ippolito as Stallone, in a performance being tipped for a best actor Oscar nomination, alongside AnnaSophia Robb, Tracy Letts and Jay Duplass. Amazon/MGM plans a US release from 6 November, though the article notes Stallone himself, who is not financially involved in the project despite reportedly viewing and approving the finished cut, could make or break its awards prospects depending on whether he publicly endorses or criticises it, given his past disputes with original Rocky producer Irwin Winkler over profit shares.
In short
- "I Play Rocky" wowed TIFF audiences despite mixed critical reviews.
- Anthony Ippolito's Stallone portrayal tipped for a best actor Oscar nod.
- Sylvester Stallone's reaction could sway the film's awards chances.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A warm audience response and Ippolito’s performance suggest the film may have the emotional reach and craft to connect with awards voters, much as Rocky and Green Book did after crowd-pleasing premieres. Its account of the story behind a much-loved film could also offer a fresh perspective, while Stallone’s reported approval of the finished cut may reassure audiences that it treats his work respectfully.
The case against
A divided critical response may indicate that the film’s appeal relies more on nostalgia and audience enthusiasm than on the sustained critical support often needed for an awards campaign. Comparisons with Rocky and Green Book do not guarantee a similar outcome, and Stallone’s complicated history with the original producers could make any public endorsement or criticism a distracting influence on the film’s reception.
Explained simply
Rocky was a 1976 film about an underdog boxer, written by and starring Sylvester Stallone. It became a major success and won the best picture Oscar in 1977, helping turn Stallone into a star.
I Play Rocky tells the story of how that film came about, with Anthony Ippolito playing Stallone. Peter Farrelly, its director, previously made Green Book, which won best picture after a mixed critical response and a warm reception from audiences.
Awards attention can affect a film’s visibility and commercial prospects. Stallone’s view may draw particular interest because he is the subject of the new film and has had public disputes with Rocky producer Irwin Winkler over profits from the original.