News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
City street shut during Covid set to remain closed
Developed over time first seen 2 months ago
Division Street, a Sheffield city centre road that was temporarily closed to traffic during the Covid pandemic in 2020, is set to be permanently shut under new council plans. Sheffield City Council is proposing to spend £170,000 on making the closure permanent, aiming to improve walking, wheeling and cycling routes between the city centre, the university and nearby neighbourhoods. The move also aims to support local businesses and hospitality venues by creating a more welcoming city centre environment.
Division Street, closed between Westfield Terrace and Rockingham Street via an experimental traffic regulation order, was shut alongside Upper Pinstone Street in June 2020, with buses rerouted around the city centre to accommodate the changes. An earlier permanent closure proposal has been scrapped in favour of a revised scheme, and councillors on the finance and performance policy committee will be asked on Monday to approve raising the budget from £126,000 to £170,000. The scheme forms part of a wider plan to create a greener city centre with cleaner air and better public transport access, with the council also seeking funding from the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority.
- Sources
- 3
- Outlets
- 3
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 1 · 0
In short
- Sheffield's Division Street to stay closed to traffic permanently
- Council proposes £170,000, up from £126,000 budget
- Aims to boost walking, cycling and local business footfall
How this story developed
- 2 months ago Sheffield City Council is pressing ahead with plans to permanently close Division Street to traffic, having originally shut it in June 2020 as a temporary Covid-era measure.
- 2 months ago Division Street, a Sheffield city centre road that was temporarily closed to traffic during the Covid pandemic in 2020, is set to be permanently shut under new council plans.
- 2 months ago Sheffield City Council is moving ahead with plans to permanently close Division Street to traffic, with a report to councillors confirming that the temporary closure has now effectively been formalised through an experimental traffic order.
- 2 months ago Division Street in Sheffield city centre, closed to traffic since June 2020 as a temporary Covid pandemic measure, looks set to become permanently pedestrianised under new council plans.
- The Star (Sheffield) Sheffield city centre street will remain closed to traffic permanently
- YorkshireLive Sheffield Sheffield city centre street shut during Covid set to be closed for good
- feeds.bbci.co.uk City street shut during Covid set to remain closed
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Converting this experimental closure into a permanent pedestrian-focused street represents an opportunity to create a more liveable city centre. Removing through-traffic would establish a safer, more welcoming environment that encourages walking and cycling between the university, city centre, and surrounding neighbourhoods, supporting local hospitality businesses whilst advancing environmental and public health objectives of reduced air pollution and sustainable urban design.
The case against
Permanent closure removes a traffic route that serves practical transport needs, forcing vehicles onto alternative roads and potentially creating congestion elsewhere in the city. This disadvantages those unable to walk or cycle—including elderly residents, disabled people, delivery drivers and others dependent on vehicles—and at a time of budget pressures, the £170,000 expenditure to formalise an existing pandemic-era closure warrants scrutiny about whether this represents genuine community demand and the best use of council resources.
Explained simply
Sheffield City Council closed Division Street, in the city centre, to traffic in June 2020 as one of several measures brought in during the pandemic to give pedestrians more space and support social distancing. Buses were rerouted around the closed section at the time, along with the neighbouring Upper Pinstone Street.
Rather than reopening the street once Covid restrictions eased, the council has been reviewing whether to make the closure permanent, treating it as part of a longer-term plan to improve walking, wheeling and cycling routes linking the city centre, the university and nearby neighbourhoods. This fits into a broader aim of reducing traffic and improving air quality in the city centre while supporting local shops, bars and restaurants.
The decision now rests with the council's finance and performance policy committee, which oversees how such schemes are funded, and the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority, a regional body that can provide additional money for transport projects. Their involvement matters because turning a temporary road closure into a permanent one affects traffic patterns, bus routes and local businesses, and requires council budgets to be formally approved.