Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
“Filmmaker” suing PassThePopcorn may be banned user out for revenge
A man using the name Matthew Schneider filed a copyright lawsuit last September against six major private torrent trackers, including PassThePopcorn, BroadcasTheNet and HDBits, claiming to be an independent filmmaker whose work was being pirated. The case had sought to unmask the trackers' operators via Cloudflare, but it unravelled after the trackers told the court that the real filmmaker behind the cited films had sworn he had no connection to the lawsuit, prompting suspicion that the plaintiff is actually a banned tracker user seeking revenge.
Facing a judge's warning of possible sanctions for a frivolous or deceptive claim, the plaintiff voluntarily dropped the case this week, but that may not spare him. Defence lawyer Erin Russell said at least one defendant will still pursue sanctions, and evidence tied to the plaintiff's email address suggests he was previously banned from a private tracker for selling or trading invites. At the next hearing, scheduled for 2 October, the plaintiff must appear on camera and provide a copy of the film he claims to have made, along with a sworn affidavit, as the court tries to establish his true identity.
In short
- Alleged filmmaker suing torrent trackers may be a banned user in disguise
- Plaintiff dropped lawsuit but still faces possible court sanctions
- Next hearing on 2 October may reveal his true identity
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The trackers can argue that a copyright suit brought in a filmmaker’s name should be scrutinised if the filmmaker denies involvement and evidence suggests the claimant may have a personal grievance. Seeking sanctions could deter deceptive litigation, protect defendants from costly claims and uphold the court’s process. Their case is strongest if the evidence shows deliberate misrepresentation rather than a mistaken or poorly supported claim.
The case against
The plaintiff can argue that withdrawing the case after the judge raised concerns is not, by itself, proof of deliberate deception, and that allegations about a tracker ban or revenge remain unproven. Sanctions could be excessive if the court has not established who he is, what he intended, and whether he had a reasonable basis for filing; fair process requires those questions to be tested before punishment.
Explained simply
Private torrent trackers are websites where members share files through the BitTorrent system. Some restrict access to invited users and focus on particular types of media, including films. PassThePopcorn, BroadcasTheNet and HDBits are among the trackers named in the lawsuit.
Copyright owners can take legal action when they believe their work is being shared without permission. The man who filed this case said he was an independent filmmaker, but the filmmaker linked to the films cited in the claim reportedly denied any connection to it. Evidence about the claimant’s email address has also raised questions about whether he was previously banned from a tracker.
The case matters because the court was asked to help identify the people running the sites, and a judge raised the possibility of sanctions if the claim was deceptive or lacked a proper basis. The dispute also touches on how courts handle claims when a person’s identity or right to bring a copyright case is uncertain.