Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Delusional’ Mairi McAllan defends dismal Pisa results saying success ‘should not be judged’ on school test results
Scotland's Education Secretary Mairi McAllan has defended the country's worst-ever performance in the international Pisa study for 2025 by arguing that educational success should not be judged solely on test scores at age 15. Her statement drew sharp criticism from opposition MSPs, who branded her response "delusional" and accused the SNP government of prioritising ideology over academic results. The controversy deepened when the Scottish Conservatives announced a schools summit featuring former UK Education Secretary Michael Gove, and McAllan declined to commit to attending.
McAllan cited alternative measures of educational success, noting that 95.7 per cent of Scottish school leavers enter positive destinations and that care-experienced young people moving into positive outcomes has risen from 58.1 per cent to 84.1 per cent since 2009–10. However, education experts have highlighted that the narrowing attainment gap shown in Pisa reflects a steeper decline in performance among less deprived pupils than among more deprived ones. Conservative MSP Meghan Gallacher pointed to England's academies expansion, curriculum reforms and phonics screening as potential lessons, whilst McAllan countered that she would not prioritise learning from architects of Conservative austerity affecting Scottish schools.
In short
- Scotland achieves worst Pisa results on record; Education Secretary rejects test-score judgment
- McAllan cites alternative success metrics; opposition calls response "delusional"
- Conservatives invite Michael Gove to education summit; McAllan refuses to attend
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
McAllan’s case is that education serves broader aims than performance on one test at age 15, including helping pupils progress into work, further study or training and supporting care-experienced young people. Positive-destination figures therefore offer relevant evidence of success, while Pisa results should still prompt scrutiny without becoming the sole measure of schools or pupils. She may also reasonably question whether reforms associated with England’s academies and curriculum can be transferred to Scotland, given differences in policy and funding context.
The case against
Critics’ case is that Pisa provides a useful international measure of pupils’ skills, and Scotland’s worst-ever results deserve a direct response rather than emphasis on other indicators. Positive destinations do not show whether pupils are developing strong literacy, numeracy and problem-solving skills, and the reported narrowing of the attainment gap may reflect falling scores among less deprived pupils rather than progress for disadvantaged pupils. Examining England’s reforms could offer practical lessons, regardless of disagreements over the wider record of Conservative governments.
Explained simply
Pisa is an international study that tests 15-year-olds in reading, maths and science, allowing results to be compared across countries and over time. It is one way of assessing education, though it does not measure every aspect of a pupil’s development or a school’s work.
Mairi McAllan is Scotland’s Education Secretary, responsible for the Scottish Government’s education policy. The Scottish Government is led by the SNP, while opposition MSPs, including the Conservatives, scrutinise its decisions and propose alternatives.
The debate matters because test results can inform judgements about pupils’ learning and how well the education system is working. Scotland’s school-leaver destinations and outcomes for care-experienced young people are other measures cited in discussions about educational success.
Government Politics Research Science World