Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘The man’s a psychopath when it comes to hedgerows’: Derek vs Derek, the unexpectedly heartwarming doc about farmers at war
The documentary *Derek vs Derek* follows two Devon farmers with opposing approaches: Derek Gow is restoring his land to nature, while Derek Banbury runs an intensive cattle and crop farm. Initially presented as neighbours locked in a bitter dispute over rewilding, food production and environmental decline, the film becomes an unexpectedly warm portrait of how shared humour, determination and a love of animals help them find common ground.
Filmmaker James Dawson began by documenting Gow’s rewilding project, including efforts to restore beavers and other species, but changed direction after meeting Banbury. Gow condemns intensive farming and ineffective conservation bureaucracy, while Banbury insists that large-scale agriculture is essential to feed a growing population and says he will not change after 50 years in farming. Their contrasting personalities and arguments, including a dispute over fire-safety arrangements for a film screening in Banbury’s barn, provide much of the documentary’s humour and human interest.
In short
- Two Devon farmers clash over rewilding and intensive agriculture.
- A documentary reveals unexpected humour and shared affection.
- Their hostility gradually gives way to cautious common ground.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Rewilding advocates argue that restoring habitats and species can help address biodiversity loss and environmental decline, and that farming practices should change where they damage the natural systems on which food production depends. They may also see intensive farming as a sign that short-term output has taken priority over long-term care of the land.
The case against
Farmers who rely on intensive methods argue that large-scale agriculture is essential to produce enough food, and that changing established practices after decades of farming is not straightforward. They may see rewilding as valuable but worry that it cannot replace productive farmland or meet society’s food needs on its own.
Explained simply
Farmers manage land in different ways, balancing food production with the health of wildlife and habitats. Rewilding aims to restore natural processes and allow species to return, while intensive farming uses land and resources to produce food on a large scale.
Derek Gow and Derek Banbury are Devon farmers with sharply different views on those choices. Gow is restoring land for nature, including work to bring back beavers; Banbury runs a large cattle and crop farm and argues that this kind of agriculture is needed to feed people.
Their disagreement reflects wider debates about how the countryside should be managed and how food can be produced while protecting wildlife. The two men’s approaches also show why those debates can be difficult to separate from farmers’ livelihoods, experience and attachment to the land.
Art Culture Entertainment Film UK World