Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Resident Evil film succeeds through its inept, relatable protagonist
Developed over time first seen 2 months ago
PC Gamer has argued that Zach Cregger's Resident Evil is the best videogame film adaptation, largely because it centres on an inept and relatable protagonist rather than familiar franchise heroes such as Leon or Chris. By presenting an ordinary person whose mistakes create both authentic survival horror and situational humour, the film succeeds where other game-to-film projects often fail. The choice to focus on character vulnerability rather than established fan-favourite heroes makes for more compelling cinema and demonstrates that authenticity can trump fan service.
The protagonist Bryan repeatedly wastes ammunition, mishandles weapons, crashes vehicles and abandons the hospital, before gradually becoming more capable as the film progresses. This trajectory mirrors players' typical progression through a Resident Evil game—from panic and helplessness to growing confidence—making the film feel authentic to the experience of playing the games despite its original story and narrative liberties. The article notes that the film remains effective as horror even for viewers unfamiliar with the series, suggesting that its strength lies in genuine character development and survival authenticity rather than lore familiarity.
- Sources
- 2
- Outlets
- 2
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- PC Gamer claims Resident Evil is the best videogame film due to its relatable, ordinary protagonist
- Bryan's ineptitude and gradual competence mirror authentic player progression
- The film works as horror for newcomers despite inventing its own story
How this story developed
- 2 months ago The outlet reinforces this assessment by emphasising Bryan's emotional fragility and ineptitude as the film's decisive strength, arguing that such vulnerability creates an authentic gameplay experience despite the narrative's departure from the franchise's established canon.
- 2 months ago The review further suggests that this approach succeeds precisely because it recreates the emotional and mechanical experience of playing Resident Evil rather than adapting its established characters or storylines, allowing protagonist Bryan's incompetence to generate both genuine horror and natural humour.
- 2 months ago PC Gamer contends that Zach Cregger's Resident Evil surpasses other videogame films by centring on an ordinary, mistake-prone protagonist whose bumbling journey toward competence authentically mirrors how players progress through the games themselves.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The film succeeds by centring on an inept, relatable protagonist whose mistakes and gradual growth mirror authentic Resident Evil gameplay, creating genuine survival horror through character development rather than fan service. By focusing on an ordinary person, the film generates earned emotional investment through vulnerability and authenticity. This demonstrates that character development and emotional truth matter more to compelling cinema than pre-existing fan recognition.
The case against
Using an established franchise hero rather than an original inept protagonist would have honoured the character arcs already developed through the games and the fan investment those figures command. An ordinary protagonist who repeatedly fails risks frustrating rather than endearing audiences, whereas proven characters offer deeper emotional resonance through established narratives. The film's critical success may owe more to strong direction and production values than to this specific creative choice, and effective adaptation need not substitute lesser-known originals for characters already developed with considerable depth.
Explained simply
Resident Evil, a new film directed by Zach Cregger, has been praised by critics for being an effective video game adaptation. Rather than centring on established characters from the game series like Leon or Chris, it features Bryan, an ordinary and somewhat bumbling protagonist who must survive the events of the film.
Video game films have a poor track record, often failing to capture what makes the original games compelling. This film takes a different approach by focusing on an inept character whose mistakes and gradual improvement mirror how players typically experience survival horror games—starting panicked and helpless, then slowly gaining competence.
The film's reliance on character vulnerability and authentic survival scenarios rather than fan service suggests a potential blueprint for successful game-to-film projects. It works as horror even for viewers unfamiliar with the Resident Evil franchise, indicating that the film's appeal extends beyond existing fans.
Coverage · 2 sources
Entertainment Film Gaming Horror
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by PC Gamer as “Resident Evil is the best videogame movie because Bryan sucks”.