News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
‘Cult’ priest denies sexually assaulting women
Chris Brain, a former Church of England priest, has denied raping or indecently assaulting women connected to the Nine O’Clock Service, which he led in Sheffield from 1986 to 1995. He accepts having consensual sexual contact with some congregation members, but rejects prosecutors’ claims that he deliberately created a cult that made young women emotionally dependent on him and vulnerable to abuse.
The court heard that the service grew from a progressive, music-led church gathering into a congregation of hundreds before collapsing amid allegations about Brain’s conduct. He said women sometimes massaged him at home to help with back tension, and that this only very rarely became sexual; he is being retried after a previous jury could not reach verdicts on one rape charge and four indecent-assault charges, while continuing to deny offences for which he was convicted last year.
In short
- Former priest denies sexually assaulting women in his congregation.
- Brain says sexual contact was consensual.
- Prosecutors allege he engineered a dependent cult-like environment.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The prosecution’s case is that Brain’s authority as a priest and the close-knit, rapidly growing congregation gave him substantial influence over women who trusted him. If he deliberately encouraged emotional dependence and used that position to obtain sexual contact, apparent agreement would not by itself settle whether he committed the alleged offences.
The case against
Brain’s defence is that the prosecution has not proved he created dependence or used his role to secure non-consensual contact, and that the relationships and occasional sexual encounters were consensual. He acknowledges sexual contact with some congregation members while denying the alleged rape and assaults, so the jury must assess the evidence for each charge rather than infer guilt from his position or the service’s later collapse.
Explained simply
The Nine O’Clock Service was a Church of England gathering in Sheffield, led by Chris Brain from 1986 to 1995. It began as a progressive, music-led service and grew to attract hundreds of people, including many young adults.
Brain was its priest and central leader. The case concerns women connected to the congregation and whether sexual contact with them was consensual or involved assault; Brain accepts some consensual sexual contact but denies the alleged offences.
The service collapsed amid allegations about Brain’s conduct. The case matters because it examines the relationship between a religious leader and people in his congregation, and the extent to which his influence affected their ability to consent.