The article argues that England’s World Cup failure should not be blamed solely on Thomas Tuchel, despite widespread criticism of his decisions during the semi-final defeat by Argentina. Tuchel’s appointment was always vulnerable to a hostile narrative, particularly because he is German and has not appeared sufficiently contrite after narrow defeats, but focusing on his perceived failings risks obscuring deeper problems within England’s football system.

England’s progress under Gareth Southgate, from dysfunction to sustained success, shows that managerial criticism can become detached from results and context. The next two years offer a major opportunity: Euro 2028 will be played partly at home, England have a strong squad, and Tuchel remains a highly capable manager, giving the team perhaps its clearest near-term chance of winning a major tournament.