Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Every Ryan Murphy ‘Monster’ Season, Ranked
Ryan Murphy's Netflix anthology series Monster, which has run since 2021, dramatises high-profile American murderers with varying creative success across its seasons. The article ranks the seasons based on their execution, noting that whilst each has delivered compelling performances and storytelling, certain creative choices have undermined their impact.
This ranking article examines individual seasons, with particular focus on Season 3 (Ed Gein) and Season 4 (Lizzie Borden). Season 3, despite stellar performances from Charlie Hunnam and Laurie Metcalf, ranks lowest due to excessive pop culture tangents exploring how Ed Gein inspired Hollywood horror films, pulling focus from the central character and creating tonal inconsistencies, including an incongruous surreal dance sequence. Season 4 made history by featuring the series' first female killer in Lizzie Borden, moving beyond the familiar nursery rhyme associations.
In short
- Monster seasons vary in quality; Season 3 undermined itself with excessive pop culture diversions.
- Strong performances anchor the series despite creative missteps in storytelling.
- Season 4 broke new ground by featuring the first female killer, Lizzie Borden.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The pop culture contextualisation in Season 3 serves an important artistic function, demonstrating how true crimes become mythologised and transform into cultural touchstones. This approach provides valuable meta-commentary that enriches viewer understanding, exploring the relationship between reality and artistic interpretation. The surreal elements represent a deliberate creative experiment rather than a narrative failure, attempting to capture psychological dimensions that conventional dramatisation cannot access.
The case against
The pop culture tangents in Season 3 fundamentally undermine the season's dramatic coherence by shifting focus away from its central subject. This fragmentation dissipates narrative tension and tonal consistency, particularly through elements like the incongruous surreal dance sequence, which confuse the season's purpose and diminish its impact. A strong dramatisation succeeds through disciplined focus on character and story, both compromised when the lens diverts to external cultural products.
Explained simply
Ryan Murphy’s Monster is a Netflix anthology series: each season tells a different story about a notorious American murderer. The seasons use real people and events as their starting point, while shaping them into television drama.
The article compares the seasons’ storytelling and performances, including seasons about Ed Gein and Lizzie Borden. Gein’s crimes later influenced well-known horror films, while Borden was accused of killing her father and stepmother in 1892 and became the subject of a famous nursery rhyme.
The series’ choices matter because they affect how viewers understand the people and events being dramatised. Its seasons have drawn attention both for their acting and for how they balance historical material with invented or stylised scenes.