Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
Critical Role Just Revealed the Dirtiest Dungeon Master Trick of All Time
Critical Role’s Campaign 4 shows Dungeon Master Brennan Lee Mulligan using a powerful magical axe to create political complications for the players. The weapon, passed between characters, was recognised by a noble who may expose a web of lies and damage the Schemers’ carefully built alliance.
The axe was originally given by Lady Ingrid Einfasen to Sir Julien Davinos, then passed to Teor Pridesire and ultimately Azune Nayar after Teor’s death. Its strong statistics encouraged multiple characters to replace their old weapons, but Mulligan used its personal history and mechanical appeal as “player bait”, creating consequences without making the item explicitly cursed.
In short
- A powerful axe threatens to expose the players’ political deception.
- Its romantic history makes the weapon plot-significant.
- Mulligan turns tempting magic items into sources of trouble.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
This represents intelligent worldbuilding that makes the game world feel alive and consequential. A powerful magical artefact would naturally have a history and political entanglements in a realistic setting. Mulligan gave the players genuine mechanical advantage whilst creating meaningful narrative stakes—they weren't forced to accept the axe, and the layered consequences reward investment in the world. This approach creates the memorable, dramatic storytelling that makes tabletop gaming compelling.
The case against
This constitutes a subtle manipulation of player agency that exploits the distinction between mechanical and narrative choice. Players select items based on statistics, not expecting hidden political complications to follow automatically. Using mechanical appeal as 'bait' to funnel players into predetermined narrative situations they didn't explicitly consent to undermines the trust essential to collaborative play. Fair DMing either makes such consequences transparent beforehand or respects player autonomy to decline items with hidden strings attached.
Explained simply
Critical Role is a series in which a group of performers play Dungeons & Dragons, a tabletop game where one person runs the story and the others play its characters. In Campaign 4, Dungeon Master Brennan Lee Mulligan guides the players through a fantasy world of rival groups, political alliances and dangerous choices.
Magic weapons can help characters in a fight, but they may also have histories and connections to people in the story. The axe first belonged to Sir Julien Davinos, was later carried by Teor Pridesire and then passed to Azune Nayar; its original giver, Lady Ingrid Einfasen, is a noble who may recognise it.
That history matters because the Schemers have built an alliance around a web of lies. A useful weapon can appeal to players while also creating new risks for their characters if others learn who once owned it.