Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Former Starfield designer says Bethesda’s sci-fi RPG probably won’t get a sequel, because the original wasn’t ‘anywhere near successful enough’
A former Starfield designer believes Bethesda is unlikely to make a sequel to the sci-fi role-playing game. They attribute this mainly to the original’s performance, saying it was not successful enough to justify continuing the series.
The comments are presented as an individual former developer’s assessment, rather than an official announcement from Bethesda. No confirmed sequel cancellation, sales figures or specific commercial targets are provided in the available article text.
In short
- Former designer doubts Starfield will receive a sequel.
- The original reportedly underperformed commercially.
- Bethesda has not officially confirmed cancellation.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Starfield's troubled launch, mixed critical reception on gameplay depth, and apparent failure to achieve expected momentum for a major Microsoft exclusive suggest meaningful performance shortcomings. When combined with the substantial investment required and the game's apparent underperformance relative to targets, these factors provide reasonable grounds for questioning whether a sequel is commercially justified, particularly given the risks and costs involved in franchise continuation.
The case against
By objective commercial standards, Starfield was successful—it sold millions of copies, became Game Pass's most successful exclusive, and generated substantial revenue. The expectation that a game must achieve mainstream cultural ubiquity to warrant a sequel is unrealistic; sequels typically depend on sustained profitability and player engagement, which Starfield demonstrably possesses. Moreover, as a former employee speaking without access to current financial data, the designer cannot speak authoritatively to how Bethesda internally assesses the franchise's viability.
Explained simply
Starfield is a science-fiction role-playing game developed and published by Bethesda, one of the world's largest video game studios. Released in 2023, it was one of the company's most ambitious projects, featuring a vast universe to explore across numerous planets.
Video game sequels are typically planned based on how commercially successful the original title was. Large investments in a new game are usually only justified if the first instalment sold well enough to suggest a sequel would be profitable. A former designer's comments about Starfield's commercial performance therefore carry weight in discussions about the game's future.
The former developer's assessment represents a personal view rather than an official statement from Bethesda, and the company has not confirmed or denied plans for a sequel. Without access to official sales figures or the studio's internal decision-making, such comments from those involved in the project offer only insider perspective rather than certainty about what comes next.
Celebrity Culture Entertainment Fashion Gaming