World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Josh Hartnett leads Newfoundland thriller about a creature beneath the bay
Developed over time first seen 2 months ago
Netflix's six-episode thriller Below opens memorably in 1986 Newfoundland with a house transported by barge across a bay that is sunk by something beneath the water. This striking scene draws on the region's real history of government-sponsored resettlement, grounding the creature feature in authentic detail and allowing it to balance practical storytelling with fantastical Spielbergian invention.
Set 40 years later, the series stars Josh Hartnett as fisherman Calvin Penney in the declining town of Snook's Arm, where residents face a relocation vote as the fishing industry collapses. When a Portuguese fishing vessel vanishes, a strange oily iceberg appears, and people start disappearing, prompting Penney to investigate with marine zoologist Fonda Howander. The six episodes, each approximately 40 minutes long, form a brisk creature mystery with uneven characterisation that blends community drama with monster-thriller suspense.
- Sources
- 3
- Outlets
- 3
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Netflix creature thriller opens with 1986 Newfoundland house-sinking disaster, grounded in real regional history.
- Fisherman investigates mysterious vanishings as strange iceberg threatens declining coastal town.
- Six episodes balance authentic setting with Spielbergian creature-feature sensibilities.
How this story developed
- 1 month ago Critical response noted the series fails to sustain the impact of its striking opening scene, with reviewers citing uneven characterisation and inconsistent accents among the performers.
- 2 months ago The series weaves psychological depth throughout, intertwining the protagonist's unresolved trauma with commentary on grief, economic hardship and climate anxiety, transcending its creature-feature format to explore broader social themes.
- 2 months ago Netflix's six-episode thriller Below, starring Josh Hartnett as a Newfoundland fisherman, sees him investigating strange occurrences in his economically struggling hometown after a Portuguese vessel vanishes and an oily iceberg appears.
- Variety Josh Hartnett Leads Netflix’s Exhilarating Sea Monster Thriller ‘Below’: TV Review
- The Hollywood Reporter ‘Below’ Review: Josh Hartnett Battles a Sea Creature in Netflix’s Likably Silly Newfoundland-Set Thriller
- Collider Josh Hartnett’s Netflix Thriller ‘Below’ Subverts Its ‘Jaws’-Style Horror With Deeper Themes | Review
Full account
Jesse McKeown's latest venture for Netflix presents a six-episode limited series that endeavours to synthesise elements of creature-driven horror with character-focused drama. The programme, titled 'Below,' unfolds across roughly forty to forty-five minutes per episode and attempts to ground its fantastical premise within the authentic context of Newfoundland, Canada—a region with documented experience of government-orchestrated population transfers in contemporary history. This geographical specificity provides an unusual foundation for what might otherwise be dismissed as straightforward genre entertainment.
The narrative traces backward initially to 1986, presenting a family's relocation via houseboat across Newfoundland waters. An unseen aquatic presence destroys the vessel; young Calvin must sever the towline, inadvertently condemning his father. Forty years hence, the adult Calvin (Josh Hartnett) inhabits Snook's Arm, a settlement teetering on extinction. Having shifted from commercial fishing to harvesting glacial ice for a vodka manufacturer, the community faces an imminent government-mandated relocation vote. Calvin's three adult children return for a ceremonial homecoming period, coinciding with an unprecedented iceberg's arrival and the onset of alarming local incidents. His sister Ruth serves as harbourmaster, and various family members—including a son whose relationship with alcohol and pharmaceutical self-medication proves consequential—become entangled in escalating peculiarities.
The series inhabits an uncertain territory between credible specificity and genre contrivance. Its opening genuinely reflects historical precedent, lending gravitas to subsequent supernatural developments. Yet critical assessments have noted the juxtaposition of authentically filmed Newfoundland locations alongside unconvincing vocal performances and digital creatures. Thematically, the programme concerns itself with how communities respond to economic collapse and demographic decline, exploring generational trauma, inherited obligation, and the psychological mechanisms by which individuals rationalise untenable situations. Environmental degradation and climate implications feature prominently within certain critical frameworks examining the narrative's deeper preoccupations.
Reviewers have articulated divergent interpretations regarding the series' aspirations and achievements. Whilst some find merit in its efficiency and thematic seriousness—perceiving an earnest examination of contemporary anxieties—others adopt a more sardonic perspective, categorising it as an entertainingly unambitious creature feature that occasionally exceeds its natural ceiling. Ensemble performances receive mixed assessment, with particular notice accorded to how individual actors navigate the region's linguistic particularities. The programme ultimately occupies an ambiguous critical space: technically competent entertainment that simultaneously reaches toward examination of contemporary societal fractures, without consistently achieving either objective with complete conviction.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
Source 2 uniquely emphasises climate crisis implications and isolates Episode 4 for particular praise; provides character specifics regarding Wade's ADHD self-medication and introduces Dr. Fonda Howander, absent from other sources
Source 3 extensively contextualises the narrative within documented Newfoundland resettlement history and explicitly references McKeown's prior work on The Umbrella Academy; neither detail appears in Sources 1-2
Critical tone diverges: Source 3 adopts sardonic, playful scepticism describing it as 'silly creature feature'; Sources 1-2 present more earnest critical appreciation
The 1986 opening and father's death receive varying levels of detail: Sources 2-3 extensively describe the mechanics of the tragedy during house relocation; Source 1 mentions the death's occurrence and emotional weight without detailing the specific incident
Government relocation vote and its procedural mechanics receive fuller treatment in Source 3; Sources 1-2 reference it more peripherally
Explained simply
Below is a new Netflix thriller series starring Josh Hartnett, combining creature horror with a story grounded in real historical events. The series opens in 1986 with a scene showing a family's house being transported by barge across a Newfoundland bay before something beneath the water sinks it. This opening draws on the region's actual history of government-sponsored resettlement programmes that displaced communities.
The story then shifts to the present day, following fisherman Calvin Penney in the fictional town of Snook's Arm as the local fishing industry declines. When a Portuguese fishing vessel disappears and an oily iceberg appears offshore, people in the community begin to vanish. Penney and a marine zoologist named Fonda Howander investigate what may be causing the disappearances.
At its heart, the series explores pressures facing real coastal communities struggling with economic decline and the decision of whether to accept government relocation money. The six episodes, each running approximately 40 minutes, blend creature-based thriller elements with character-driven storytelling rooted in these broader social themes.
Coverage · 3 sources
- ColliderJosh Hartnett’s Netflix Thriller ‘Below’ Subverts Its ‘Jaws’-Style Horror With Deeper Themes | Review
- VarietyJosh Hartnett Leads Netflix’s Exhilarating Sea Monster Thriller ‘Below’: TV Review
- The Hollywood Reporter‘Below’ Review: Josh Hartnett Battles a Sea Creature in Netflix’s Likably Silly Newfoundland-Set Thriller
Americas Art Business Celebrity Culture Entertainment Fashion Horror Markets Paranormal Research Science TV Weird & Viral World