Xbox Polling Players on Whether Fallout, Elder Scrolls, or Even Minecraft Should Go Exclusive
Xbox is asking a select group of Xbox Insiders whether making major franchises such as Fallout, The Elder Scrolls and Minecraft exclusive to Xbox and PC would affect their buying choices. The poll matters because it tests whether exclusivity could draw players to Xbox or PC, while Microsoft considers how to grow revenue from its gaming business.
The survey asks about responses including upgrading to an Xbox, switching to PC or skipping the games, and considers a scenario in which all Xbox-developed franchises except Call of Duty become console exclusive. For Minecraft, the scenario would also stop sales and updates on PlayStation and Nintendo, while leaving previously owned content unaffected. The article notes that Gears of War: E-Day is estimated to have sold 310,000 copies across Xbox and PC, though Game Pass players are not included in that figure.
- Xbox is surveying Insiders about making major series exclusive.
- The poll asks whether players would switch platforms or skip games.
- Minecraft sales and updates on rival consoles feature in one scenario.
New here? Start with this
Microsoft owns Xbox and the game studios behind series such as Fallout, The Elder Scrolls and Minecraft. These games have been released on several platforms, including PlayStation and Nintendo consoles, as well as Xbox and PC.
Console exclusivity means a game can be played only on certain systems. Microsoft’s choices about where to release its games can affect players deciding which console or computer to buy, and the company’s efforts to earn revenue from its gaming business.
Xbox Insiders are players who sign up to try features and give Microsoft feedback. Their responses can show how some players might react to changes in where games are sold, though a poll does not mean a decision has been made.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Making major franchises exclusive could give players a clearer reason to buy an Xbox or play on PC, helping Microsoft recoup development costs and invest in future games. Supporters may also argue that platform-specific games strengthen the Xbox ecosystem and make subscription services such as Game Pass more valuable.
The case against
Keeping these franchises available across platforms lets more people play them and preserves communities built around shared games, particularly for Minecraft. Critics may argue that removing access from PlayStation and Nintendo users would alienate existing fans, reduce potential sales, and make the games less appealing overall.