1973, Iggy Pop dismissed an album as “filler”. Kurt Cobain, Johnny Marr and Henry Rollins saw a masterpiece
Iggy Pop said he considered only about four songs on The Stooges’ 1973 album *Raw Power* really good, describing the rest as filler. The article contrasts his reservations with the album’s lasting influence on punk and later musicians.
Kurt Cobain praised the record as an example of how punk should sound, while Johnny Marr admired Pop as a singer and Henry Rollins valued the album’s understated political edge. Rollins connected its references to napalm and combat with the Vietnam War, illustrating how listeners found meaning in music that Pop felt fell short of his aims.
In short
- Iggy Pop thought much of *Raw Power* was filler.
- Kurt Cobain, Johnny Marr and Henry Rollins admired its influence.
- Rollins heard a subtle Vietnam War theme in the album.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Pop’s reservations are a reasonable judgement of his own work: he felt only a few songs met his standards, and may have heard the rest as falling short of what he intended. An artist’s view of an album’s quality can differ from its later reputation, and calling tracks filler need not deny their importance to other listeners.
The case against
The album’s influence and the admiration of musicians such as Cobain, Marr and Rollins support seeing it as a coherent, significant work, even if Pop was dissatisfied with parts of it. Listeners could value its sound, performance and political undertones on their own terms, finding meaning and impact beyond the artist’s original aims.
Americas Entertainment Music World