Gabby Petito court battle could decide whether Charlie Kirk family can prevail in Utah wrongful death lawsuit
A Utah Supreme Court appeal arising from Gabby Petito’s 2021 murder could affect whether Charlie Kirk’s family can bring a wrongful death claim over alleged security failures before his killing. An attorney involved in the Petito appeal says a ruling overturning a 1996 precedent could clear a legal barrier for the Kirk family.
The precedent, known as Tiede, upheld Utah’s governmental immunity law as it applies to wrongful death claims involving assaults by third parties. Petito’s family sued Moab police over their response to a traffic stop involving Brian Laundrie, but a judge dismissed the case on immunity grounds. Kirk’s family filed a notice of claim in September, alleging Utah Valley University, the state and officials failed to secure the event; prosecutors say Kirk was shot by a sniper positioned across the courtyard. The article also says his lawyers have prepared the groundwork for a possible federal claim.
In short
- A Utah appeal could shape the legal path for the Kirk family.
- A 1996 ruling limits some wrongful death claims against government bodies.
- Kirk’s family alleges officials failed to secure the event.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Petito appeal could give Kirk’s family a fair opportunity to have its allegations heard in court. If public bodies or officials negligently failed to provide reasonable security, immunity should not automatically prevent accountability, particularly where a death is alleged to have resulted from those failures.
The case against
Governmental immunity protects public bodies from liability in circumstances where the law says they should not be treated like private defendants, including some harms caused by third parties. Keeping the Tiede precedent could provide legal certainty and avoid making public institutions liable for criminal acts they did not commit, while leaving any separate federal claim to be assessed on its own merits.
Explained simply
Utah’s governmental immunity law limits when people can sue public bodies and officials. In some cases involving harm caused by another person, the law may shield them from wrongful death claims, even when a family alleges that public authorities failed to act.
Gabby Petito was killed by Brian Laundrie in 2021, and her family sued Moab police over their response to a traffic stop involving the pair. A judge dismissed the case under immunity rules, which draw on a 1996 Utah Supreme Court precedent known as Tiede; the Petito family’s appeal asks the court to revisit that precedent.
Charlie Kirk’s family has filed a notice of claim alleging that Utah Valley University, the state and officials failed to secure an event before Kirk was shot. How Utah’s immunity rules apply could affect whether a wrongful death claim against public bodies can proceed, while his lawyers have also prepared for a possible federal claim.