Omar’s deleted tweet could give clue on alleged brother marriage
A deleted 2013 post in which Rep. Ilhan Omar referred to her father as “Nur Said” has resurfaced as federal investigators examine her identity and immigration records. The name resembles part of her former husband Ahmed Nur Said Elmi’s name, but that similarity does not establish a family relationship.
Omar has denied that Elmi is her brother and said her real name is Ilhan Abdullahi Omar; her office disputes claims that she used another legal name. A court filing linked to the investigation lists “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi” as an alias but does not explain the reference or show that she used a false identity. Her former marriage to Elmi ended in 2017, and she later married Ahmed Hirsi.
In short
- A deleted post referred to Omar’s father as “Nur Said”.
- Omar denies marrying her brother or using a false identity.
- A court filing lists another name but does not explain why.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The resurfaced post and the alias in a court filing may reasonably prompt questions about whether investigators have found relevant details in Omar’s identity or immigration records. Given the public interest in accurate disclosures by an elected representative, supporters of scrutiny argue that the records should be examined carefully and any substantiated findings explained.
The case against
A resemblance between a name in a post and part of a former husband’s name does not establish that they were related, and the filing does not explain the alias or show that Omar used a false identity. Treating these fragments as evidence of a brother marriage risks turning an unproven allegation into a conclusion; fair scrutiny should account for Omar’s denial and wait for verifiable evidence.
Explained simply
Ilhan Omar is a US politician who represents Minnesota in Congress. She was born in Somalia and moved to the United States as a refugee. Her personal and immigration records have drawn scrutiny, including claims about her past marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi.
Omar has denied that Elmi was her brother and says her name is Ilhan Abdullahi Omar. A court filing connected to an investigation lists “Ilhan Nur Said Elmi” as an alias, but does not explain why or establish that she used a false identity. A resemblance between names alone cannot show a family relationship.