STEPHEN GLOVER: Burnham’s comments on slavery are his most destructive blunder yet. This is a man ill-suited to the world stage
The article argues that Andy Burnham’s reported openness to apologising for Britain’s role in the slave trade was a serious political mistake, particularly ahead of a meeting of Commonwealth leaders. It claims his comments could strengthen calls for reparations and create diplomatic or financial consequences.
The writer contrasts an apology, which he says could imply responsibility, with expressions of sorrow such as those King Charles has made during his Caribbean tour. The article cites a UN judge’s estimate of £18 trillion in reparations, describing it as about six times Britain’s national debt and annual economic output. It also refers to Burnham’s earlier remarks on Scottish independence and closer EU ties as examples of what the writer sees as impulsive statements.
In short
- Burnham’s remarks on slavery drew criticism ahead of a Commonwealth leaders’ meeting.
- The article distinguishes an apology from expressions of sorrow.
- It cites an £18 trillion reparations estimate.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A formal apology from a British political leader could be read as accepting continuing responsibility and might strengthen demands for reparations, with potentially significant diplomatic and financial consequences. Ahead of a Commonwealth meeting, advocates of caution would argue that expressions of sorrow can acknowledge the suffering caused by slavery while avoiding commitments whose scope and effects have not been carefully considered.
The case against
An apology could be defended as an honest recognition of Britain’s historical role in slavery and of the lasting harm it caused, rather than as an automatic acceptance of a particular reparations bill. Advocates may argue that careful acknowledgement can build trust with Commonwealth countries and support a serious discussion of redress; avoiding an apology for fear of its possible implications could seem evasive and strain those relationships.
Explained simply
The transatlantic slave trade was a system in which millions of Africans were forcibly taken and enslaved, including in British colonies. Britain played a major role in the trade and later abolished it; the effects of slavery remain part of debate in Britain and across the Commonwealth, an association of countries, many with past ties to the British Empire.
Andy Burnham is the Labour mayor of Greater Manchester and a prominent British politician. Governments and campaigners in some countries have called for apologies or reparations—payments or other forms of redress—for slavery and its lasting effects. An apology and an expression of sorrow can carry different political and legal meanings, though neither automatically determines whether compensation is owed.