World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Colts’ Jonathan Taylor deserves to be sent to ‘contender’ if traded, former teammate says
Former Indianapolis Colts quarterback Nick Foles says that if the rebuilding team trades All-Pro running back Jonathan Taylor, it should send him to a contender. Foles said he would prefer to keep Taylor as a teammate, but understands the business case for seeking valuable draft picks.
The 27-year-old Taylor is reportedly available alongside quarterback Daniel Jones and receiver Josh Downs, with the Colts said to want a steep return comparable to the picks San Francisco gave up for Christian McCaffrey. Taylor is under contract through the 2028 season, which could appeal to teams seeking help beyond this year; the New York Giants, Denver Broncos and Minnesota Vikings have been linked to interest. The trade deadline is 4 p.m. ET on Tuesday.
In short
- Nick Foles says Taylor deserves a move to a contender if traded.
- Indianapolis is rebuilding and reportedly seeking a high draft-pick return.
- The Giants, Broncos and Vikings have been linked to interest.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
If the Colts decide to trade Jonathan Taylor, sending him to a contender could reward an accomplished player with a chance to compete for a title, while respecting the value he has given the club. It may also make a deal more attractive to Taylor and potential buyers, helping Indianapolis secure a strong return as it rebuilds.
The case against
The Colts have Taylor under contract through 2028, and keeping an All-Pro running back could give the team a foundation for its rebuild rather than relying on uncertain draft picks. Trading him to a contender might strengthen a rival while leaving Indianapolis without a proven player at a demanding position; the club could reasonably prioritise the best return or decide that retaining him serves its plans better.