Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Each new GTA moves the series closer and closer to the original Mafia, the open-world game that bettered Rockstar
The article argues that the Grand Theft Auto series has gradually moved towards the more grounded, historically detailed approach seen in the original Mafia. Released in 2002, Mafia offered a crime story shaped by the Prohibition era and a carefully changing city, qualities the writer sees echoed in Rockstar’s later games.
Mafia follows taxi driver Tommy Angelo as he joins the Salieri crime family in Lost Heaven, a fictional 1930s city modelled on Chicago. Its streets, buildings and cars change over time, while traffic rules, public transport, finite fuel and realistic ammunition add detail. The article says GTA 3 had far greater influence, but suggests Mafia showed another direction for open-world crime games that Rockstar has increasingly explored.
In short
- The original Mafia offered a more grounded crime-game approach.
- Lost Heaven changes as its story moves through the 1930s.
- The writer sees later GTA games adopting some of Mafia’s ideas.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Mafia’s period setting, evolving city and attention to everyday details showed how an open-world crime game could make its world feel historically grounded and shape the story around a particular place. Rockstar’s later games can be seen as moving closer to that approach, suggesting Mafia offered a valuable alternative direction even if GTA 3 had greater influence.
The case against
The similarities may reflect broad ambitions shared by crime games rather than a specific path from Mafia to GTA. GTA 3 had the larger influence on the genre, and Rockstar’s later settings and realism can be understood as developments of its own evolving series, not as a move towards Mafia.
Explained simply
Grand Theft Auto and Mafia are open-world crime games, in which players can explore a city while following a story. The first Mafia, released in 2002, is set in the 1930s and follows taxi driver Tommy Angelo as he becomes involved with the Salieri crime family in the fictional city of Lost Heaven.
Mafia’s streets, buildings and cars change as the story progresses, and the game includes details such as traffic rules, public transport and limited fuel. The article compares this grounded, period-specific approach with later Grand Theft Auto games, while noting that GTA 3 had a much greater influence on the genre.