Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Long-term plan for welfare can’t mask case for urgent reform
Former Labour minister Alan Milburn is due to call for a “complete system reset” to address the number of young people not in education, employment or training. His proposed 10-year, whole-of-government plan would increase spending upfront to improve support and achieve savings over time; the article argues that longer-term change is needed, but urgent action on barriers to hiring is also necessary.
Milburn’s report is expected to involve schools, colleges, the NHS, employers, local authorities and government agencies, and aims to prevent the number of NEETs reaching 1.27 million by 2031. The welfare bill is forecast to rise from £333 billion to £431 billion by the end of the decade, while the Conservatives say their proposed reforms would save £36 billion annually. The article also highlights a tension in Milburn’s proposals: subsidies and possible National Insurance reductions for employers could help young people find work, even as tax rises on employers are criticised for making hiring harder.
In short
- Milburn proposes a 10-year welfare reset to help young people.
- NEET numbers could reach 1.27 million by 2031.
- The article calls for long-term support and urgent hiring reform.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A decade-long, cross-government plan could address the causes of young people becoming detached from education and work, rather than relying on short-term measures after problems have escalated. Upfront investment in health, education and employment support may help more young people find lasting work and reduce welfare costs over time; targeted employer subsidies or National Insurance relief could also make hiring easier.
The case against
With many young people already out of education and work, a plan whose savings and results may take years risks leaving immediate barriers unaddressed. Critics can argue that the scale of the rising welfare bill calls for faster reforms with measurable near-term savings, and that higher taxes or costs for employers may discourage the very hiring needed to improve young people’s prospects.