World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Widow, 95, faces £1m court bill after decade-long row with neighbours’ who accused her of being ‘poisonous’ over disputed garden fence boundary between their country homes
A 95-year-old widow, Mary Egan, has lost her appeal over who should pay the legal costs of a decade-long boundary dispute with her neighbours, leaving her facing a bill of more than £1 million. The case began after Neil and Fiona Morgan put up a fence beside their country home in Kent; although a court found they had trespassed on Egan’s land, it treated the overall result as a draw.
The dispute concerned a strip of land about 60 metres long. In 2021, a judge dismissed the Morgans’ claim that Egan had damaged their fence and awarded her £2,600 in damages, plus £3,250 after allowing the third fence to remain as the boundary; he rejected her preferred boundary line through a hedge. A later costs ruling required each side to pay its own legal expenses, and the High Court has now dismissed Egan’s appeal against that decision.
In short
- A 95-year-old widow faces legal costs exceeding £1 million.
- A court found her neighbours had trespassed over a fence boundary.
- The High Court upheld the decision that each side pays its own costs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The costs ruling can be defended on the basis that the dispute produced mixed results: the Morgans were found to have trespassed, but Egan did not secure her preferred boundary and the court treated the overall outcome as a draw. Requiring each side to bear its own legal costs may therefore be seen as a fair way to reflect that neither party wholly prevailed.
The case against
Egan’s appeal can be supported by the view that the Morgans’ trespass was a central part of the dispute, and that she obtained damages and a ruling allowing the third fence to remain as the boundary. Given the scale of the resulting bill for a 95-year-old, she could argue that making her absorb her own legal costs leaves her bearing an excessive burden despite those findings in her favour.
Explained simply
Property boundary disputes in England can turn on deeds, old features such as hedges, and evidence about how land has been used. Courts may decide that one neighbour crossed a boundary while still rejecting the other neighbour’s preferred line or claim.
Mary Egan and her neighbours, Neil and Fiona Morgan, argued over a strip of land beside their country homes in Kent. A court found the Morgans had trespassed on Egan’s land, but it also rejected her proposed boundary through a hedge and allowed a fence to remain.
When neither side was treated as the overall winner, the court ordered each to pay its own legal costs. Those costs can grow over years of litigation, so the ruling has left Egan facing a bill reported to exceed £1 million.