Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
New CA wealth tax tactic emerges after billionaire tax went down in flames
California Medical Association chief executive Dustin Corcoran is exploring a 2028 ballot initiative to restructure California’s income tax, potentially creating a new contest over whether the state’s wealthiest residents should pay more. The proposal is at an early stage, with no rates or revenue estimates, but Corcoran says the campaign would seek broader backing and direct funds to health care, education and workforce development.
The effort follows voters’ rejection of Proposition 40, which proposed a one-time 5% tax on billionaires and was defeated by 52.8% to 47.2%; supporters had projected about $100 billion in revenue, largely for health care. The union behind that measure says it may return with another proposal, while Governor Gavin Newsom and wealthy technology figures opposed it. Proposition 42, also passed by voters, bars new taxes targeting assets, which could constrain any plan that reaches beyond income.
In short
- A 2028 income tax overhaul is being explored in California.
- Proposition 40’s one-time billionaire tax lost by 52.8% to 47.2%.
- A union-backed tax proposal may return as groups weigh alternatives.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that restructuring income tax to ask more of the wealthiest Californians is a more broadly grounded and workable way to raise funds than a one-off tax on billionaire assets. Directing revenue to health care, education and workforce development could address public needs and strengthen the services and skills on which the state’s economy depends.
The case against
Opponents could argue that higher taxes on top earners may encourage wealthy residents and businesses to relocate, reducing investment and ultimately weakening the tax base. With the proposal still lacking rates or revenue estimates, they may also question whether it would reliably fund public services, and whether another tax campaign respects voters’ recent rejection of a billionaire tax.
Explained simply
California voters recently rejected Proposition 40, a proposed one-off tax on billionaires’ wealth that supporters said could raise about $100 billion, mainly for health care. The state’s income tax, by contrast, is charged on money people earn.
Dustin Corcoran, head of the California Medical Association, is exploring a 2028 ballot measure to change how that income tax works, with proceeds intended for health care, education and job training. The idea is at an early stage, and no tax rates or revenue estimates have been announced.
The proposal could renew debate over how much California’s wealthiest residents should pay. Any plan based on taxing assets may face limits under Proposition 42, which voters approved to bar new taxes targeting assets; the union behind Proposition 40 has also said it may put forward another measure.
Business Companies Elections Politics World