New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Skylar Grey Takes Issue With Olivia Rodrigo & Phoebe Bridgers’ Rock Grammy Nominations
Skylar Grey has criticised the Grammys’ Best Rock Performance nominations, objecting to Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers being included. In a social media video, she contrasted their nominated songs with “R.I.P.” by Motionless In White, which features her, and urged the Grammys to “do better”.
“R.I.P.” is currently number one on Billboard’s Mainstream Rock Airplay chart, but the article notes that Rodrigo and other pop or folk artists also appear across Billboard’s rock charts. The piece questions whether radio play, an awards category or an individual listener can define rock, amid wider debate over how the Grammys assign genres.
In short
- Skylar Grey questioned the Grammys’ rock nominations.
- Her featured track “R.I.P.” leads Billboard’s Mainstream Rock Airplay chart.
- The story highlights how difficult genre boundaries are to define.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Grammys’ rock categories should have meaningful stylistic boundaries, and nominations ought to reflect the sound and traditions listeners reasonably associate with rock. Grey’s comparison highlights a concern that broad genre definitions can sideline artists whose work is more conventionally rock, weakening the category’s usefulness to audiences and musicians.
The case against
Rock has always borrowed from other styles, so a song need not fit a narrow sound or an artist’s usual genre to merit recognition. Rodrigo’s and Bridgers’ nominations can be defended on the music itself, while chart placement and radio formats are imperfect measures of genre; flexible categories may better reflect how listeners and artists understand music today.
Explained simply
The Grammys are the US music industry’s annual awards, with recordings grouped into categories such as Best Rock Performance. These categories recognise work released during a set eligibility period, and the nominees are chosen by members of the Recording Academy.
Genre labels can be disputed because artists often mix musical styles, and the Grammys’ categories do not always match how radio stations or listeners describe a song. Rock radio airplay charts measure plays on selected stations; they are one way to track a song’s reach, but they do not settle what counts as rock.
Skylar Grey is a singer and songwriter whose work includes collaborations with rock acts. Olivia Rodrigo is known mainly as a pop artist, while Phoebe Bridgers is associated with indie and folk rock. Their inclusion in a rock category sits within a broader debate about how awards classify music that crosses genre lines.