Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Universal and Sony fight Suno’s bid to freeze second lawsuit, warning its latest AI models could escape scrutiny until at least 2028
Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment are opposing Suno’s request to pause their second copyright lawsuit, arguing that a full stay could leave its newer AI models beyond scrutiny until at least 2028. The dispute matters because the labels say Suno is continuing to train, release and make money from models while the legal questions about its use of recordings remain unresolved.
Suno asked the court to wait for a decision on fair use in the first lawsuit, which was filed in June 2024. The second suit, filed on 18 September, alleges that Suno copied 60,202 recordings without permission; statutory damages for wilful infringement could theoretically exceed US$9 billion, and the labels are also seeking an order to stop further use. They would accept delaying proof of ownership until the first case’s fair-use ruling, but want discovery about later models, licensing, fundraising and finances to proceed; summary judgment motions in the first case are due by 22 June 2027.
In short
- Universal and Sony oppose pausing their second Suno lawsuit.
- They say a full stay could defer scrutiny until 2028.
- The case concerns 60,202 recordings and newer AI models.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The labels can argue that pausing the entire second case would leave important questions about Suno’s later models, licensing and continued use of recordings unexamined for years, even as the company keeps releasing models and earning revenue. Allowing targeted discovery now could preserve evidence and help the court assess whether further use should be stopped, while postponing ownership issues that may depend on the first case’s fair-use ruling.
The case against
Suno can argue that the first lawsuit is already addressing the central question of whether its training practices qualify as fair use, so proceeding with overlapping litigation risks duplicative discovery, expense and inconsistent rulings. Waiting for that decision could narrow or resolve the second case, making the process more efficient and avoiding broad demands for financial and technical information before the key legal issue is settled.
Explained simply
Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment are two of the world’s biggest record companies. Suno is a company that makes AI software for generating music. The labels say Suno used recordings they own to train its models without permission; Suno disputes their claims and has asked the court to pause a second lawsuit while an earlier case is decided.
The cases raise questions about how copyright law applies when AI systems learn from existing music. The outcome could affect what music companies can control, what AI firms need permission to use, and how these services develop and earn money.
AI Research Science Technology