Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Early Yellow seeks master royalties over JACKBOYS track sample
Developed over time first seen 1 day ago
Israeli producer Niv Kalisky, known as Early Yellow, sued Travis Scott, Don Toliver and others over “What To Do?”, a 2019 JACKBOYS track. He alleges that he supplied a sample beat used in the recording and is owed master royalties, a claim concerning his share of the sound recording’s revenue.
Kalisky is credited as a songwriter and additional producer and receives publishing income, but says he has not received master royalties despite repeated requests for payment and accounting statements. The lawsuit also names Sheck Wes, Cactus Jack, Sony’s Epic Records and other producers, and seeks a portion of revenue from sales, streaming and licensing. “What To Do?” reached No. 56 on the Billboard Hot 100, while the JACKBOYS album debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200; the defendants had not commented at publication.
- Sources
- 2
- Outlets
- 2
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Early Yellow says he is owed master royalties for a sample in “What To Do?”
- The lawsuit seeks a share of sales, streaming and licensing revenue.
- The track appeared on the chart-topping 2019 JACKBOYS album.
How this story developed
- 16 hours ago Kalisky’s latest claims add that Cactus Jack and Epic Records did not respond to repeated requests for payment records, and that Sony countered his requests to streaming services to take down the track.
- 22 hours ago The lawsuit also seeks a share of revenue from synchronisation licensing, alongside earnings from sales and streaming, while Kalisky says he has received publishing income as a credited songwriter and additional producer.
- 22 hours ago Producer Niv Kalisky, known as Early Yellow, sued Travis Scott, Don Toliver and others over alleged unpaid master royalties for a sample beat he says he supplied for the 2019 JACKBOYS track “What To Do?”.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Kalisky’s claim rests on the distinction between publishing income and royalties from the sound recording: if his sample beat contributed to the finished master and the parties agreed he would share in its revenue, he should receive the promised accounting and payment. His songwriting and additional-production credits, along with his account of repeated requests, give a reasonable basis for seeking a court’s determination of what he is owed.
The case against
A credit for songwriting or additional production does not by itself establish an entitlement to master royalties; that depends on the agreements and the specific contribution made to the recording. The defendants may have a good-faith basis to dispute whether Kalisky was promised a share of recording revenue, or how any such share should be calculated, and the claim remains an allegation until resolved.
Explained simply
JACKBOYS is a music collective associated with rapper Travis Scott, and “What To Do?” is a track from its 2019 album. The song also features Don Toliver and includes work by producer Niv Kalisky, who records as Early Yellow.
Music can generate different kinds of income: songwriting and publishing payments go to the people credited for the composition, while master royalties come from use of the recorded track. Kalisky says he has received publishing income but is owed a share of recording revenue for a sample beat he says was used in the song.
The dispute involves the artists, producers, their label and other companies connected to the release. It raises questions about how recording income is accounted for and shared among the people involved in making a commercially successful track.
Coverage · 2 sources
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Billboard as “Travis Scott and Don Toliver Sued Over Sample on Hit JACKBOYS Track ‘What To Do?’”.