Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Australia’s ‘problematic’ surrogacy laws could be transformed under proposed changes
Australia’s Law Reform Commission has proposed changes to make surrogacy easier to access and safer, while keeping the ban on commercial surrogacy. It says the current patchwork of laws and criminal penalties pushes intended parents towards overseas or hidden arrangements, where risks of harm and exploitation may be greater.
The 47 recommendations include a consistent national framework, licensed support organisations, increased compensation for surrogates and clearer safeguards over a child’s legal parents. Compensation would cover medical costs, lost earnings including superannuation, birth support and other pregnancy-related expenses. Estimated domestic gestational surrogacy births rose from 27 in 2014 to 84 in 2023, while overseas births increased from 246 in 2015 to 375 in 2024; the report is now before the federal attorney general.
In short
- Australia’s law reform body recommends a national surrogacy framework.
- Commercial surrogacy would remain banned, with greater expense compensation.
- Overseas surrogacy births rose by more than 40% from 2015 to 2024.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A consistent national framework, stronger safeguards and better support could make surrogacy safer for children and surrogates while reducing the need for intended parents to seek arrangements overseas or outside the law. Allowing compensation for pregnancy-related costs and lost earnings may also make domestic surrogacy more accessible without permitting payment for carrying a child.
The case against
Even with commercial surrogacy banned, broader access and increased compensation could make pregnancy more financially attractive and risk undue pressure on people who agree to become surrogates. A cautious approach may prioritise preventing exploitation and protecting children and surrogates, especially where safeguards are difficult to enforce, over making surrogacy easier to arrange.
Explained simply
Surrogacy is an arrangement in which a person carries a pregnancy for someone who plans to raise the child. In gestational surrogacy, the surrogate has no genetic link to the child; Australian law also recognises traditional surrogacy, where the surrogate’s own egg is used.
Australia bans paying a surrogate for the arrangement itself, but allows some pregnancy-related costs to be reimbursed. Rules differ between states and territories, and criminal penalties apply to some arrangements, including certain overseas ones. This means people seeking surrogacy may face different legal requirements depending on where they live.
The proposed changes concern how surrogacy is supported, how expenses are covered and how a child’s legal parents are established. The issue matters to intended parents, surrogates and children, as well as to efforts to reduce the risks associated with arrangements made outside regulated systems.