Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Alan Milburn has issued a wake-up call on NEETs, but Labour’s not listening
Alan Milburn’s final review on young people and work warns that the costs and obligations imposed on employers are contributing to the NEET crisis, and that further regulation could weaken hiring. Helen Whately argues that Labour has failed to heed those warnings, risking young people’s prospects and business confidence.
The article says more than a third of employers plan to hire fewer permanent staff because of the Employment Rights Act. Whately points to higher employer National Insurance, minimum wage costs and business rates, and says ministers have focused on the review’s spending recommendations while neglecting its concerns about business. She sets out Conservative proposals including halving employer National Insurance for under-25s, work requirements for some Universal Credit claimants and £36bn in welfare savings.
In short
- Milburn warns employer costs and regulation are harming young people’s job prospects.
- More than a third of employers plan to reduce permanent hiring.
- Whately urges Labour to back business-focused measures and welfare reform.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Whately’s argument say that when hiring costs and regulatory obligations rise, employers may offer fewer permanent jobs, making it harder for young people to gain experience and move into work. They argue that targeted cuts to employer National Insurance and clearer work expectations could improve job opportunities, business confidence and incentives to seek work.
The case against
Critics could argue that the review identifies a complex NEET problem that cannot be solved by reducing employer costs or tightening benefit conditions alone. They may favour investment in tailored support, skills and access to suitable work, and argue that employment protections and a fair minimum wage help ensure jobs are secure and worthwhile; they could also question whether the proposed tax cuts and welfare savings would deliver the promised gains.
Explained simply
NEET is a term for young people who are not in education, employment or training. Alan Milburn’s review examines why some young people struggle to move into work and what could help them; employers’ willingness to recruit is one part of that picture.
The debate involves the government, employers and opposition politicians. Employers face costs such as wages, National Insurance contributions and business rates, while rules on workers’ rights set conditions for hiring and employment. The question is how these factors affect businesses’ recruitment decisions and young people’s access to jobs.
Welfare policy is also part of the discussion, including what support people receive and whether some benefits come with requirements to seek work. Choices about employer costs, employment rules and welfare can affect both businesses’ staffing plans and young people’s routes into work.