World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Inquest hears newborn’s doula left to inflate jumping castle after home birth
An inquest heard that a newborn, known as Baby DH, died just over eight hours after a home birth near Byron Bay, amid conflicting accounts of whether his parents were reassured about his condition. The hearing is examining four babies who died after free births or home births in northern New South Wales between 2022 and 2024, and what support and medical care were available.
The parents said their doula, Amy Lou Smith, repeatedly reassured them despite the baby appearing purple, floppy, cold and struggling to breathe, and later left to attend to a jumping castle. Smith disputed parts of their account, saying everything seemed OK and that the parents were free to seek medical help; she denied giving clinical advice. A neonatologist told the court the baby had a complex heart defect that could have been treated, and that his death was not inevitable.
In short
- A newborn died hours after a home birth near Byron Bay.
- Parents and doula gave conflicting accounts of the baby’s condition.
- A specialist said the heart defect could have been treated.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The parents’ account, if accepted, raises serious questions about whether the doula’s reassurance and departure delayed urgent medical care for a newborn showing alarming symptoms. The neonatologist’s evidence that the heart defect was treatable supports examining whether earlier assessment might have changed the outcome, while recognising that the inquest is still weighing the evidence.
The case against
Smith disputes key parts of the parents’ account, says the baby appeared well to her and denies giving clinical advice; she says the parents remained free to seek medical help. A fair assessment should distinguish a doula’s non-clinical support role from medical responsibility and avoid treating the tragic outcome as proof that her conduct caused it, especially while the accounts remain contested.
Explained simply
A doula provides practical and emotional support during pregnancy and birth, but is not a doctor or midwife and does not provide medical care. A “free birth” usually means giving birth without a midwife or doctor in attendance; a home birth may involve a midwife or other trained professional.
The inquest is examining four babies who died after free births or home births in northern New South Wales between 2022 and 2024. It is considering what support and medical care were available, and the different accounts of the help offered after Baby DH was born.
The hearing has also heard that Baby DH had a complex heart defect and that treatment was possible. Its findings may help clarify how support and access to medical care are handled when babies are born at home.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “‘I didn’t notice his body being purple’: Byron Bay doula left newborn to inflate a jumping castle, court hears”.