Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Labour’s Lucy Powell sparks confusion as she says Government ‘will look at’ making school uniform porn illegal – despite victims minister resisting a ban
Labour deputy leader and Education Secretary Lucy Powell said the Government would look at whether to ban pornography featuring adults in school uniform. Her comments followed a campaign by four Oxfordshire pupils, whose petition has gained more than 70,000 signatures, and highlighted disagreement within Government over whether a legal ban is the right response.
The Crime and Policing Act, passed in April, bans online pornography depicting someone pretending to be under 16, but does not cover cases where school uniform alone suggests childhood. Victims minister Alex Davies-Jones said criminal law could be a blunt tool and questioned how a uniform would be defined, arguing that wider cultural sexualisation also needed attention. She cited sexualised school-uniform costumes sold by retailers and Britney Spears’s “Baby One More Time” video as examples.
In short
- Lucy Powell said the Government would examine a possible ban.
- A pupils’ petition has attracted more than 70,000 signatures.
- The victims minister questioned whether criminal law is the answer.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A ban could close a gap in the law where pornography uses school uniform to signal childhood without depicting someone pretending to be under 16. Supporters may argue that this imagery reinforces the sexualisation of children and that clear legal limits would respond to pupils’ concerns and help protect children.
The case against
A ban could be difficult to define and enforce fairly, since school-style clothing can appear in varied contexts and a uniform alone does not establish that a performer is underage. Critics may argue that criminal law is too blunt for this problem and that tackling wider cultural sexualisation, alongside existing protections, would be more effective.
Explained simply
Lucy Powell is Labour’s deputy leader and Education Secretary, while Alex Davies-Jones is the victims minister. The debate concerns pornography showing adults dressed in school uniform and whether it should be covered by a specific legal ban.
The Crime and Policing Act, passed in April, bans online pornography depicting someone pretending to be under 16. It does not cover material where a school uniform alone suggests the person is a child, leaving questions about how such a ban could be defined and enforced.
Four pupils in Oxfordshire have campaigned for a ban, and their petition has attracted more than 70,000 signatures. The issue also raises broader questions about sexualised portrayals of school-age children and whether criminal law is the right way to address them.
Elections Government Politics World