World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial
Professor Peter Hindmarsh, whose evidence supported the prosecution case that Lucy Letby poisoned babies with insulin, was barred from treating patients during her trial because his hospital considered his advice on insulin unsafe. The jury was not told, and Letby’s defence was not informed of the restriction, raising questions about whether they could properly challenge his credibility as an expert witness.
Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice by University College London Hospitals in March 2023; a tribunal later required direct supervision but did not suspend his medical registration. Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, and is seeking a referral of her case to the Court of Appeal through the Criminal Cases Review Commission. Medical experts have disputed the prosecution’s case, while Hindmarsh declined to comment.
In short
- Hindmarsh was barred from treating patients during Letby’s trial.
- The jury and defence were not told about the hospital’s safety concerns.
- Letby’s case is under review by the miscarriage of justice watchdog.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The restriction may have been relevant to assessing Hindmarsh’s reliability: if his hospital considered his insulin advice unsafe, the defence could reasonably argue that the jury should have known and been able to question him about it. Fair trials depend on meaningful scrutiny of expert evidence, especially where that evidence supports serious criminal charges.
The case against
A restriction on clinical practice does not by itself establish that Hindmarsh’s trial evidence was wrong or that he was unfit to give expert testimony; the tribunal required supervision but did not suspend his registration. Whether the jury needed to hear about the restriction depends on its connection to the specific evidence and the rules governing disclosure, and the conviction should be assessed on the full trial record rather than this fact alone.
Explained simply
Lucy Letby, a neonatal nurse at the Countess of Chester Hospital, was convicted of murdering seven babies and trying to murder seven others. The prosecution argued that she harmed some babies by giving them insulin, a hormone that controls blood sugar.
Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a doctor specialising in children’s hormones, gave evidence for the prosecution about insulin. Expert witnesses can help juries understand medical evidence, while the defence can question their methods and reliability.
Letby is seeking to have her case referred to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which reviews possible miscarriages of justice. Disagreement among medical experts about the evidence has made the assessment of the trial evidence a matter of public interest.