World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Exclusive: Labour MPs quit Somaliland group over Israel and chair’s ties to far-right Restore
Two Labour MPs have resigned from, or withdrawn their support for, the UK’s all-party parliamentary group on Somaliland, amid disputes over its direction, Israel and its Conservative chair, Gavin Williamson. Labour MP Kim Johnson said an Israeli official’s attendance at a parliamentary event was the final straw, while Abtisam Mohamed cited long-standing differences; Kerry McCarthy has suspended her involvement pending Williamson’s resignation.
The group has not met since before Parliament’s summer recess, following Israel’s recognition of Somaliland and scrutiny of Williamson’s ties to the anti-immigration party Restore Britain. Johnson said Israel’s recognition had deepened divisions in communities, while she and Mohamed stressed their continuing support for Somaliland’s people. A report written by Williamson argued that recognition could bring strategic and economic benefits, including access to Somaliland’s resources and a possible UK military base at Berbera.
In short
- Two Labour MPs have left the Somaliland parliamentary group.
- Israel’s recognition of Somaliland and the group’s direction fuelled divisions.
- A third Labour MP has stopped taking part pending the chair’s resignation.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the group’s current direction could argue that Israel’s recognition of Somaliland and closer engagement with it may advance Somaliland’s international standing and bring practical benefits, such as trade, investment and security cooperation. They may see parliamentary events involving Israeli representatives as legitimate discussion of those possibilities, and argue that the group should be able to pursue them despite disagreement over its chair’s wider political associations.
The case against
Critics could argue that Israel’s recognition has sharpened divisions and that giving an Israeli official a platform risks undermining trust among communities already affected by the issue. They may also judge that Williamson’s reported ties to Restore Britain and the group’s focus on strategic assets and a possible military base compromise its credibility, making resignation or suspension a principled way to press for a different direction while continuing to support Somaliland’s people.
Explained simply
Somaliland is a self-declared republic in the Horn of Africa. It declared independence from Somalia in 1991 and has its own government, but it has not been widely recognised as an independent country.
All-party parliamentary groups bring MPs and peers together to discuss a particular country or issue; they are informal and separate from the government. The Somaliland group is chaired by Conservative MP Gavin Williamson. Its work has included questions about international recognition and the possible strategic and economic benefits of closer ties.
Israel’s recognition of Somaliland has become a point of disagreement among politicians, alongside questions about Williamson’s links to Restore Britain, a party that campaigns against immigration. The disputes matter because the group provides a forum for UK parliamentarians to discuss Somaliland, while recognition could affect its relations with Somalia and other countries.