Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
UC students rally to keep SAT banned even as profs warn freshmen can’t do basic math: ‘Second-rate university’
Nearly 100 University of California students rallied at UC San Francisco, urging the system to keep the SAT and ACT out of admissions. They say the tests disadvantage low-income students and students of colour, and argue that UC should improve support for students who are already enrolled. The debate matters as professors report that more incoming students are struggling with basic mathematics.
UC adopted its test-free admissions policy in 2020. A UC San Diego report cited by faculty found that the number of freshmen with maths skills below high-school level rose nearly thirtyfold over five years; 70% of that group tested below middle-school level, amounting to about one in 12 incoming students. At Berkeley, 20% to 30% of first-term calculus students showed severe preparation deficits in diagnostic tests for three consecutive years. Maths faculty are calling for SAT or ACT maths requirements for STEM applicants from 2027, while rallying students say UC should invest more in tutoring and other support.
In short
- Students want UC to keep SAT and ACT out of admissions.
- Professors report growing gaps in freshmen’s maths preparation.
- Students say more tutoring and support are needed.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Keeping the SAT and ACT out of admissions may prevent tests shaped by unequal access to preparation, and by wider socioeconomic disparities, from disadvantaging low-income students and students of colour. Students argue that gaps in preparation should be addressed with tutoring and other support after enrolment, rather than by using test scores to restrict who gets in.
The case against
The reported maths gaps suggest that some students are entering demanding courses without the foundations they need, which can hinder their progress and place added pressure on teaching and support. For STEM applicants, requiring a maths score could offer one measure of readiness and help universities identify where preparation is lacking, while retaining the policy for other applicants.
Explained simply
The University of California (UC) is a public university system with campuses across the state. In 2020, it stopped using SAT and ACT scores in admissions, amid concerns that the tests can reflect differences in students’ income and access to preparation as well as their academic ability.
The argument is about how UC should judge applicants and prepare students for university-level work. Some maths faculty want standardised test scores to help assess readiness, particularly for science and engineering courses; students who oppose bringing the tests back say the university should strengthen tutoring and other support for those it admits.
The issue matters because some UC faculty report that more students are arriving with gaps in basic maths, which can make advanced courses harder to follow. The debate weighs the potential role of admissions tests against concerns about fairness and the university’s responsibility to help students succeed.
Elections Government Politics World