World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Millionaire wages war on Saks with paid protesters after NYC mom was punched, kicked by customer — then fired
A 62-year-old Saks Fifth Avenue sales associate says a customer punched and kicked her at the Manhattan store in June; the customer later pleaded guilty to assault and aggravated harassment. Saks dismissed the employee five days after the incident, citing policy breaches and her response to the confrontation. Her son, entrepreneur Jeffrey Vinokur, is paying protesters to picket Saks and Bergdorf Goodman, demanding a public apology and changes to New York employment laws.
Vinokur says he has spent $12,600 on 15 protesters for a week at Saks, and has added a protest at Bergdorf Goodman costing $1,800 a day. He has vowed to continue the demonstrations indefinitely, including during the retailers’ holiday events. The employee says she was attacked after filming the customer, while Saks’ dismissal letter said recording violated store policy and accused her of escalating the situation and disobeying a manager.
In short
- A Saks worker was attacked and later fired.
- Her son is funding protests at Saks and Bergdorf Goodman.
- He wants a public apology and changes to employment laws.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The demonstrations can be seen as a way to draw attention to a worker who says she was assaulted and then lost her job, and to press a powerful employer to explain how it handled the incident. Supporters may argue that recording was an understandable attempt to document an attack, and that the case raises broader questions about whether workplace rules and employment laws protect workers adequately.
The case against
Saks may argue that it dismissed the employee for alleged breaches of store policy and failure to follow a manager’s instructions, rather than simply for being assaulted, and that employers must be able to enforce rules consistently. Critics of the campaign may also contend that paying protesters and targeting another retailer risks applying pressure before all the relevant facts are clear, while the customer’s guilty plea does not by itself settle whether Saks’s employment decision was fair.
Explained simply
Saks Fifth Avenue is a luxury department store in Manhattan, and Bergdorf Goodman is another high-end retailer nearby. The dispute centres on a sales associate who says a customer assaulted her at work; the customer later pleaded guilty to assault and aggravated harassment.
Saks dismissed the associate five days after the incident, citing breaches of store policy and her conduct during the confrontation. She says she was attacked after filming the customer, while the store’s letter said recording was prohibited and accused her of escalating the situation and ignoring a manager.
Her son, entrepreneur Jeffrey Vinokur, is paying people to protest outside the two stores. The dispute also raises questions about how employers handle staff who are involved in confrontations at work and what protections employment laws provide in New York.