World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Treating Cars as a Commerce Clause Hook Would Vastly Expand Federal Power, a SCOTUS Petition Warns
Derick Irisha Brown is asking the US Supreme Court to review her federal kidnapping conviction, arguing that using a car to commit a crime wholly within one state should not, by itself, bring the case under federal authority. The dispute matters because the courts disagree over whether cars are inherently instruments of interstate commerce, a reading Brown says could greatly broaden Congress’s power under the Commerce Clause.
Brown was convicted by a federal jury in September 2024 and received two concurrent life sentences; she also faces capital murder charges under Alabama law in a case that has not yet gone to trial. The 11th Circuit upheld federal jurisdiction, aligning with the 5th, 6th and 7th Circuits, while the 10th Circuit has rejected that approach. The Cato Institute supports Supreme Court review, warning that treating ordinary car use as enough could allow federal regulation of a wide range of conduct now handled by states.
In short
- Brown challenges federal jurisdiction over a kidnapping involving a car.
- The 11th and 10th Circuits have reached conflicting conclusions.
- Cato warns the ruling could expand federal power over everyday conduct.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Congress can address conduct that substantially affects interstate commerce, and cars are deeply connected to interstate transport and commerce even when a particular journey stays within one state. A broad rule may also give federal authorities a consistent basis to prosecute serious kidnappings involving vehicles, avoiding jurisdictional gaps and conflicting circuit standards.
The case against
A car’s ordinary use in a crime wholly within one state does not itself make that conduct interstate commerce, and treating it as sufficient could weaken the constitutional boundary between federal and state authority. States can prosecute local crimes, while a narrower federal rule would preserve Congress’s commerce power for conduct with a clearer connection to interstate activity.
Explained simply
The Commerce Clause is the part of the US Constitution that lets Congress regulate trade between states. Federal laws can also cover some crimes that affect interstate commerce, while crimes confined to one state are usually handled under state law.
Courts have differed over whether a car used in a crime within one state can count as an instrument of interstate commerce. Some appeals courts say it can; another has rejected that reasoning. The Supreme Court can settle disagreements between federal appeals courts.
The dispute raises questions about the boundary between federal and state authority. How broadly that boundary is drawn can affect which level of government may prosecute crimes and regulate conduct involving everyday items such as cars.