Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Embark Studios apologizes for replacing esports casters with AI voices in now-deleted The Finals video
Embark Studios has removed a recap video for The Finals esports qualifiers after backlash over replacing human commentators’ voices with AI-generated commentary. The studio’s competitive operations lead called the decision a mistake and said the video would not return in that format, underscoring tensions over how AI use affects esports talent.
The original APAC Closed Qualifiers for The Grand Major were commentated by ProtoANZ and Bluepanda, but the recap used the game’s AI commentators, Scotty and June. Embark said planned recaps for the Americas and Europe, Middle East and Africa would also be rethought. The casters criticised the apology, and ProtoANZ called for an esports talent union to seek protections against AI use of performers’ voices.
In short
- Embark removed a Finals esports recap that used AI voices.
- Planned Americas and EMEA videos are being reconsidered.
- Casters criticised the decision and called for voice protections.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Using the game’s AI commentators in a recap could offer a consistent presentation, reduce production demands and let a studio publish coverage across multiple regions more easily. Supporters may see this as a legitimate use of the game’s established characters, provided it is transparent and does not falsely imply that human casters took part.
The case against
Replacing the voices of the people who actually commentated the qualifiers risks erasing their contribution and weakening the trust between organisers and esports talent. Casters can reasonably argue that performers deserve a say in how AI reproduces or substitutes for their voices, and that collective protections may be needed to safeguard credit, consent and future work.
Explained simply
The Finals is a team-based competitive shooter made by Swedish studio Embark Studios. Its esports events bring players together to compete in regional qualifiers, with commentators explaining the action for viewers.
ProtoANZ and Bluepanda commentated the Asia-Pacific qualifiers for an event called The Grand Major. The game also has AI-generated commentators, Scotty and June, whose voices were used in the recap video.
The dispute raises questions about how esports organisers use AI voices and what protections commentators and other performers may have. It also reflects broader concerns about how AI-generated material could affect paid creative work.
AI Entertainment Gaming Technology