Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Mullin defends TSA shoes-on policy after congressman calls classified briefing ‘very concerning’
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin defended the TSA policy allowing most travellers to keep their shoes on at airport checkpoints, saying the department had addressed three of four concerns raised by its inspector general. The issue returned to focus at a House hearing after Arizona Congressman Eli Crane described a classified briefing as “very concerning” and asked Mullin to discuss it privately.
The policy began nationwide in July 2025, when then-Secretary Kristi Noem said improved screening technology could maintain security while shortening queues; officers can still require shoe removal for extra screening. The inspector general issued a final classified report on 1 November 2025, and a March memo said DHS and TSA had missed a 90-day deadline to respond. Mullin gave no details about the concerns or the department’s actions, and his testimony did not establish whether the inspector general had approved them.
In short
- Mullin says DHS addressed three of four inspector general concerns.
- Crane called a classified briefing “very concerning”.
- The TSA policy lets most travellers keep their shoes on.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Keeping shoes on can make airport screening quicker and more convenient, while updated technology and officers’ ability to require extra checks may preserve security. Mullin’s claim that the department has addressed most of the inspector general’s concerns could support continuing the policy if those steps adequately manage the identified risks.
The case against
A nationwide change to screening should be supported by clear evidence that it does not weaken security, and the classified concerns have not been publicly explained. The missed response deadline and lack of confirmation that the inspector general accepted the department’s actions give grounds to question whether the policy should continue without fuller assurance.
Explained simply
The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) screens passengers and their belongings at US airport checkpoints. In July 2025, it began allowing most travellers to keep their shoes on, citing screening technology intended to maintain security while reducing queues. Officers can still ask passengers to remove their shoes for additional checks.
The policy is overseen by the Department of Homeland Security, which includes the TSA. Its inspector general independently reviews the department’s work and issued a classified report on the policy in November 2025. Because the report is classified, its specific concerns are not public.