Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Tech outages are causing people to panic-buy. Costco is benefiting, Mizuho says
A series of technology and service outages has prompted some consumers to stock up on emergency supplies, boosting Costco sales, according to research firm Mizuho. The trend matters because it may lift the warehouse retailer’s comparable sales, although officials have said there is no reason to panic.
Mizuho estimates Costco’s US comparable sales excluding petrol rose 11% to 12% in the final week of October, compared with 6% to 7% earlier that month; Costco reported an 8.1% monthly increase. The firm said the stronger pace continued into November, with 21 of 26 high-priced generators it tracked sold out on Costco’s website as of Sunday night. Mizuho raised its price target to $1,150 from $1,100 and said November comparable sales could grow by more than 10%; Costco is due to report results on 10 December.
In short
- Outages and online alarm are driving some emergency buying.
- Mizuho estimates Costco’s late-October comparable sales rose 11% to 12%.
- The firm raised its Costco price target to $1,150.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Stocking up after technology and service disruptions can be a prudent way to prepare for interruptions to power, communications or essential services. If shoppers are buying useful supplies rather than responding to exaggerated claims, the increased demand may reflect sensible household resilience, and stronger sales would be a legitimate benefit for Costco and its investors.
The case against
Officials have said there is no reason to panic, and buying more supplies than households need can amplify fear and leave others facing shortages. The evidence cited is also an analyst’s estimate and website stock checks, so it may not establish that outages caused the sales increase or that the trend will last; treating it as a basis for investment expectations risks overstating a temporary effect.
Explained simply
Costco is a membership warehouse retailer, where shoppers pay an annual fee to buy groceries and other goods, often in large quantities. Comparable sales measure changes in sales at stores open for at least a year, helping show whether established shops are selling more than before.
Mizuho is a financial research firm that analyses companies and estimates how they may perform. Its view of Costco’s sales matters to investors because sales growth can affect expectations for the retailer’s business and share price.
People sometimes buy emergency supplies when they fear essential services may be disrupted. Officials have said there is no reason to panic, and the reported sales trend does not by itself show how widespread such concerns are.