World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Penn State criticised over lecture on decolonising Holocaust museums
Penn State faced criticism after hosting a Jewish Studies lecture asking whether Holocaust museums should be “decolonised”. The event, held on 17 November and led by former US Holocaust Memorial Museum fellow Erica Lehrer, considered whether decolonial museum practices could broaden such institutions’ social justice aims.
The event advert said Holocaust museums are often outside decolonial critiques, but are still shaped by state power and museum traditions that can involve bias and exclusion. Critics, including the Republican Party of Pennsylvania and US Holocaust Memorial Council chairman Jeff Miller, said the framing risked undermining the museums’ role in preserving the history of the murder of six million Jews and honouring victims; Penn State later deleted its Instagram post promoting the lecture.
In short
- Penn State hosted a lecture on decolonising Holocaust museums.
- Critics said the topic risked undermining their memorial role.
- The event advert questioned museums’ ties to state power and inherited practices.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Holocaust museums can honour victims and preserve the history of the genocide while also examining how their collections, interpretation and institutional traditions reflect state power or exclude some perspectives. Considering decolonial approaches may help museums engage wider audiences and pursue social justice without diminishing the Holocaust’s distinct history.
The case against
Holocaust museums have a particular responsibility to document the murder of six million Jews, honour victims and guard against distortion or minimisation of the genocide. Critics may reasonably worry that applying a broad decolonial framework could shift attention from that core mission or imply that the museums’ established work is compromised, even if the lecture intended to invite discussion rather than make that claim.
Explained simply
The Holocaust was the systematic persecution and murder of six million Jews by Nazi Germany and its collaborators during the Second World War. Holocaust museums preserve evidence and accounts of these crimes, honour those who were killed and teach visitors about their history.
Museums also make choices about which stories to tell, how to present them and whose perspectives to include. Decolonising museums means examining how colonial histories and unequal power may shape those choices; the term can cover different approaches and does not have one fixed meaning.
The debate matters because it concerns how Holocaust museums can address their history and purpose while preserving the record of the Holocaust. It also reflects wider disagreements about how museums should respond to social justice concerns.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Penn State skewered for hosting controversial lecture on arguing for ‘need to decolonize’ Holocaust museums”.