Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
The 10 greatest games to never get a GOTY nomination
The article argues that some acclaimed games have been overlooked for The Game Awards’ Game of the Year shortlist, even as the 2026 nominations drew criticism for including unreleased Grand Theft Auto 6 and excluding this year’s indies. It highlights games praised for their design and influence that received recognition in other categories but never a GOTY nomination.
Examples include Dark Souls 3, which lost out in a competitive 2016 field, and Outer Wilds, whose unconventional, combat-free approach faced strong competition in 2019. NieR:Automata’s niche origins and philosophical story may have limited its appeal to voters, while Ghost of Yotei received seven nominations in 2025 across categories including direction and narrative but missed the top award shortlist. The supplied article text ends partway through its discussion of Ghost of Yotei.
In short
- Acclaimed games have missed the Game of the Year shortlist.
- Dark Souls 3 and Outer Wilds faced crowded years.
- Ghost of Yotei received seven nominations but no GOTY nod.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A Game of the Year shortlist should recognise outstanding craft and lasting influence, not only the most commercially visible or broadly accessible releases. Games such as Dark Souls 3, Outer Wilds and NieR:Automata show how distinctive design and storytelling can merit top recognition even when they challenge familiar conventions; Ghost of Yotei’s other nominations likewise make its omission a reasonable point of debate.
The case against
A shortlist has limited places, and voters must compare games with different strengths in a crowded field; missing a nomination does not mean a game lacks quality or recognition. The examples faced strong competition, and a specialised style or unconventional structure may resonate deeply with some players while making another title a more persuasive overall choice for the award.
Explained simply
The Game Awards is an annual event that gives prizes to games across categories such as direction, storytelling and performance. Its Game of the Year shortlist is the ceremony’s highest-profile selection, but many well-reviewed games have never made it onto that list.
The shortlist is chosen from games released during the year, so strong competition can leave acclaimed titles out. Games can still receive nominations in other categories, and missing out on the top award does not mean a game had little influence or was poorly received.
Dark Souls 3, Outer Wilds and NieR:Automata are among the games often cited as notable omissions, while Ghost of Yotei received several nominations in other categories without reaching the Game of the Year shortlist. Their different styles and release years illustrate how varied games can be, and how any shortlist reflects a limited selection.