Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Treat outages as accidental unless evidence points to a cyberattack
A cluster of technology failures across the US, including disruptions affecting Microsoft services, aviation, JPMorgan Chase and the NSA, prompted speculation that a cyberattack was under way. The article says there is no evidence linking the incidents or showing they were caused by hackers, and argues that outages should be treated as accidental unless concrete evidence suggests otherwise.
Cybersecurity experts cited in the article say technical failures are far more common than attacks. Network analyst Doug Madory estimates that only about one in a thousand outages he monitors is caused by hackers; common causes include faulty updates, configuration changes, cut cables and power failures. Problems at major cloud providers can also trigger knock-on failures or make otherwise functioning services appear disrupted.
In short
- A run of US technology outages fuelled cyberattack fears.
- No evidence links the incidents or points to hackers.
- Experts say ordinary technical failures are much more common.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Treating outages as accidental unless evidence indicates an attack follows the base rate: technical faults such as faulty updates, configuration changes, cut cables and power failures are far more common than cyberattacks. This approach avoids amplifying speculation, while allowing investigators to revise their assessment if concrete evidence emerges.
The case against
A cautious, provisional suspicion of cyberattack can be justified when several high-profile services fail around the same time, since coordinated attacks may be designed to look like ordinary technical faults. Taking that possibility seriously can encourage timely investigation and preparedness, even when the incidents have not yet been linked and no evidence of hacking has been reported.
Explained simply
Cyberattacks are deliberate attempts to disrupt or gain access to computer systems. But services can also fail because of routine technical problems, such as faulty software updates, incorrect settings, damaged cables or power cuts.
Many organisations rely on the same cloud and network providers to run their systems. A fault at one provider can therefore affect several services at once, even when those organisations have not been attacked. Security experts look for concrete evidence before linking separate outages to hackers.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Ars Technica as “How to tell a cyberattack from a plain old outage”.