World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ha-Joon Chang: ‘Mexico must redesign its relationship with the US or it will sink with it’
Economist Ha-Joon Chang says Mexico should rethink its close economic integration with the United States and strengthen its own industrial capacity. He argues that free trade between countries at very different levels of development can hold the poorer country back, leaving it dependent on foreign firms and vulnerable when the stronger economy declines.
Chang says Mexico’s 1995 entry into NAFTA made it harder to build domestic computing and car industries, although the country has retained much of its earlier level of industrialisation despite China’s rise. He argues that today’s economic uncertainty makes the assumptions behind Mexico’s US-centred strategy more risky, and calls for a stronger role for the state in development, including measures such as subsidies, trade protection and requirements for local investment and employment.
In short
- Chang urges Mexico to rethink its economic reliance on the US.
- He says free trade can limit poorer countries’ industries.
- He calls for stronger state support for domestic development.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Mexico’s deep reliance on the US market and foreign firms may leave it exposed to US downturns and limit the growth of domestic industries. Supporters of Chang’s approach argue that targeted state support, local investment and employment requirements could build productive capacity and give Mexico more control over its economic future.
The case against
Close integration with the US can bring investment, jobs, technology and access to a large market, benefits that may be harder to secure through a more inward-looking strategy. Critics of protection and subsidies argue they can raise costs, invite retaliation and shelter inefficient firms, while disrupting supply chains that support Mexican workers and businesses.
Explained simply
Mexico shares a long border and extensive trade links with the United States. The two countries, along with Canada, formed the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 1994; it was replaced by a revised agreement in 2020.
Ha-Joon Chang is an economist who studies how countries develop their industries. His argument draws on a wider debate about whether countries with less developed economies benefit from open trade with richer countries, or need time and government support to build local businesses and skills.
Mexico’s economy includes manufacturing industries such as cars and electronics, alongside strong links to US companies and markets. How it balances those connections with efforts to develop domestic firms matters for jobs, investment and its exposure to changes in the US economy.
Americas Asia Business Economy World