Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Hotel guest died from carbon monoxide poisoning as chimneys were sealed, court hears
Prosecutors told Preston Crown Court that hotel guest Graham Holden, 66, died of carbon monoxide poisoning after chimney pots at the Royal Hotel in Morecambe were covered with plastic bags and duct tape. The case matters because investigators said the blocked chimneys, combined with a dangerously defective boiler, allowed poisonous fumes to build up in a room used by guests.
Holden was found dead on 6 November 2021; his death was initially attributed to heart failure, but a later post-mortem found high levels of carbon monoxide in his blood. On Boxing Day, five members of another family staying in the same room became seriously ill and were treated in hospital. The prosecution says the boiler, made in 1995, had not been serviced since the hotel was taken over in 2012, and argues the risk of death was foreseeable. Company director Liam O’Hagan denies gross negligence manslaughter and says he did not order the chimney work.
In short
- A hotel guest died from carbon monoxide poisoning.
- Prosecutors say plastic bags blocked the chimneys.
- The hotel company director denies manslaughter.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The prosecution’s case is that a dangerously defective boiler had gone unserviced for years, while the sealed chimneys prevented fumes from escaping into the room. The earlier death and the later serious illnesses, they argue, show the risk was foreseeable and that those responsible for guest safety should be held to account.
The case against
O’Hagan denies ordering the chimney work, and the court must determine what he knew, what he was responsible for and whether his conduct meets the high threshold for gross negligence manslaughter. A boiler’s age or poor maintenance alone does not establish an individual’s criminal liability; the evidence must show that his own breach of duty caused the death and was sufficiently serious to be criminal.
Explained simply
Carbon monoxide is a poisonous gas that has no smell or colour, so people may not realise they are breathing it in. Boilers can produce it if they are faulty, and chimneys help carry fumes away from rooms.
The Royal Hotel is in Morecambe, a seaside town in Lancashire. Graham Holden, a 66-year-old guest, died there in November 2021; weeks later, five people from another family staying in the same room became seriously ill and were treated in hospital.
The case concerns how the hotel was run and whether safety risks were properly managed. Company director Liam O’Hagan denies gross negligence manslaughter, a charge relating to a death caused by a serious failure to meet a duty of care.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Hotel guest, 66, died from carbon monoxide poisoning after landlord ordered chimneys to be covered with plastic bags, manslaughter trial hears”.