World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Japanese Charts: Pikmin 4 Makes A Lukewarm Debut On Switch 2 As Zelda Dominates
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remained the best-selling game in Japan, with 86,097 copies sold, while Metaphor: ReFantazio debuted in second place on Switch 2. Pikmin 4’s Switch 2 edition entered the chart near the bottom, amid criticism that it adds too little to the original.
The Pikmin edition sold 2,854 copies and ranked ninth in the article’s account, though upgrade-pack purchases by existing Switch owners are not included in that figure. Players have criticised the lack of new content, 60fps support and reports of longer loading times; its Metacritic user score was 6.4 after briefly falling to 2.3. Switch 2 led hardware sales with 42,402 units, compared with 11,136 across PS5 models, 3,754 for the original Switch and 707 for Xbox.
In short
- Ocarina of Time sold 86,097 copies to retain first place.
- Metaphor: ReFantazio debuted second on Switch 2.
- Pikmin 4’s new edition sold 2,854 copies, excluding upgrade packs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The low chart position may understate demand because it excludes upgrade-pack purchases by existing Switch owners, and a paid edition can still appeal to newcomers or players who value having the game on the newer system. Its strong original release may also make a technical reissue worthwhile if it improves the experience over time or gives more people access to it.
The case against
A Switch 2 edition is harder to justify at full price when it adds little new content and players report no 60fps support and longer loading times. Its low reported sales and sharply negative user-score reaction suggest that many players see too little improvement to warrant buying the game again.