Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Faults not fixed in 90% of homes in government insulation scheme
The government says more than 90% of homes identified with faulty external wall insulation under two energy-saving schemes have yet to be repaired. Energy Minister Martin McClusky told MPs the failures showed the schemes lacked proper oversight and said affected households would not have to pay for repairs.
Of 24,600 homes identified as needing repairs, work has been completed at 2,227. The schemes were ECO4, launched in 2022 and due to close in December, and the Great British Insulation Scheme, which has closed. Birmingham homeowner Ken Palfrey says badly fitted insulation led to damaged window sills, damp and mould; campaigners warn other defective upgrades may also be harming homes.
In short
- More than 90% of affected homes are still awaiting repairs.
- Repairs are complete at 2,227 of 24,600 homes.
- Ministers say households will not pay to fix the work.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The schemes aimed to cut energy bills and emissions, and the scale of the repair backlog does not by itself show that the original policy goals were misguided. A reasonable case for retaining such programmes is that they can help households improve inefficient homes, provided government strengthens oversight, ensures installers are accountable and completes repairs at no cost to residents.
The case against
The failures and slow repair rate suggest that rapid delivery and energy-saving targets were not matched by adequate checks on workmanship or follow-up. A reasonable case against continuing the schemes in their current form is that defective insulation can leave residents with damp, mould and damaged homes, undermining both public trust and the promised benefits; safeguards and repair capacity should be in place before further work is funded.
Explained simply
External wall insulation is fitted to the outside of a home to help keep heat in and reduce energy use. The work was supported through two government schemes: ECO4, which began in 2022, and the Great British Insulation Scheme.
The schemes involved government oversight, energy companies and contractors carrying out the work, with households receiving upgrades. Poorly fitted insulation can let in water or cause damp, mould and damage to parts of a home. The issue matters because repairs can affect residents’ health and living conditions, as well as the cost and effectiveness of public efforts to improve home energy efficiency.