Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
John Swinney apologises over Grand Theft Auto AI video
John Swinney apologised after the SNP posted and then deleted an AI-generated video styled like the Grand Theft Auto games. The clip depicted Boris Johnson and Margaret Thatcher in satirical scenes, prompting criticism from people concerned about AI’s effects on artists, workers and the environment.
The SNP said the video aimed to celebrate Scotland’s games industry and highlight political issues, while acknowledging debate over appropriate AI use. At First Minister’s Questions, Swinney said he was sorry if anyone had been offended and shared wider concerns about AI, while also pointing to possible benefits such as helping the NHS assess cancer risk. The party said Scotland’s video games industry had grown by almost 10,000% in 15 years; the remarks came amid protests against proposed large AI data centres in Scotland.
In short
- Swinney apologised over an AI-made SNP video styled as Grand Theft Auto.
- The party deleted the clip after criticism of its use of AI.
- Debate continues over AI’s benefits, risks and data centre expansion.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The SNP could argue that the video used satire to draw attention to political issues and celebrate a successful Scottish games industry, while AI can offer wider public benefits, including support for NHS cancer-risk assessment. Used thoughtfully, the technology may help create new forms of expression and practical services, and debate about its effects should guide responsible use rather than rule it out.
The case against
Critics could argue that AI-generated creative work risks displacing artists and workers, especially when it imitates a recognisable game style without adequately addressing questions of consent or compensation. They may also see the video as an avoidable use of energy-intensive technology at a time of concern about data centres’ environmental and local impacts, and question whether celebrating the industry justified those costs.
Explained simply
John Swinney is Scotland’s First Minister and leader of the Scottish National Party (SNP), which governs Scotland. The party used an AI tool to make a political video in the style of Grand Theft Auto, a well-known series of video games; it showed former UK prime ministers Boris Johnson and Margaret Thatcher in satirical scenes.
The video raised questions about how political parties should use AI, including its effects on artists, workers and the environment. The debate also comes as Scotland considers the growth of AI, from possible uses in healthcare to proposals for large data centres that have prompted protests.
AI Entertainment Gaming Government Politics Technology