World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Albany educrats are finally tackling NY’s reading disaster — but it’s too little, too late
New York’s Board of Regents has adopted rules requiring teacher preparation programmes to teach evidence-based reading instruction, known as the “science of reading”. The change addresses concerns that teachers are being credentialled without adequate training, but the article argues that the state’s timetable is too slow while pupils continue to fall behind.
The 85 teacher preparation schools overseen by the Regents have until 2028 to comply. A survey of New York educators found only 8% had received substantial preparation in evidence-based reading instruction; Mississippi, which passed literacy legislation in 2013, now outperforms New York in fourth-grade reading, including among pupils from low-income households. SUNY’s 17 teaching programmes, which graduate more than 5,000 students a year, adopted similar requirements with a deadline at the end of 2026.
In short
- New York has ordered teacher training programmes to teach evidence-based reading.
- The 85 programmes have until 2028 to comply.
- A survey found only 8% of educators had substantial preparation in this approach.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Requiring teacher preparation programmes to teach evidence-based reading instruction addresses a documented training gap and could help more pupils learn to read effectively. A phased deadline gives institutions time to revise courses and prepare staff, while SUNY’s earlier 2026 deadline shows that change is already under way.
The case against
The case for a faster timetable is that pupils struggling to read now cannot recover the time lost while programmes wait until 2028 to comply. With only 8% of surveyed educators reporting substantial preparation in evidence-based instruction, and New York trailing Mississippi in fourth-grade reading, critics can argue that the rules should take effect sooner and include stronger interim steps.