World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Labour MPs press ministers to reject Rosebank oilfield approval
At least 75 Labour MPs have urged the Prime Minister not to approve the Rosebank oilfield, arguing that drilling would not lower energy bills. The dispute could trigger a major rebellion against Andy Burnham’s government, as Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh considers whether to approve the project.
Reports suggest Fahnbulleh, a former ally of Ed Miliband, may be encouraging MPs to lobby against approval, though this is speculation. She has distinguished Rosebank from the Jackdaw gasfield, which she approved last month, saying Rosebank’s oil is mainly for export and its approval must meet climate commitments. Three of Miliband’s parliamentary private secretaries also criticised the project in a recent debate. Polling cited in the article found 52 per cent support approval and 16 per cent oppose it; support in Fahnbulleh’s Peckham constituency was lower than the national average.
In short
- At least 75 Labour MPs oppose approving Rosebank.
- Fahnbulleh is weighing the oilfield’s application.
- Polling cited shows 52 per cent support approval.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Opponents argue that Rosebank would do little to reduce household energy bills because much of its oil is expected to be exported, while adding emissions that could make climate commitments harder to meet. They see rejecting it as a way to align energy policy with the transition to cleaner power and avoid locking in further fossil-fuel production.
The case against
Supporters argue that developing domestic oil resources can contribute to energy security, sustain investment and jobs, and reduce reliance on imports, even if it does not directly lower bills. They may also contend that oil demand will persist during the transition, so production under UK regulation could be preferable to sourcing it from countries with weaker environmental standards.
Explained simply
Rosebank is a proposed oilfield in the North Sea. It would add to UK oil production, but oil from the field is expected to be mainly for export, so its development would not necessarily reduce the cost of energy for households.
The decision rests with the government, including Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, who must weigh the project against the UK’s climate commitments. Rosebank is being discussed alongside Jackdaw, a separate gasfield that the government approved last month.
The issue has divided Labour MPs and raises questions about how the government balances energy production with climate goals. It also matters for people concerned about future energy costs and the UK’s role in producing fossil fuels.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Miliband and Miatta ‘are plotting to oil the wheels of a Labour rebellion over Rosebank’”.