Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Religion should be removed from terrorism definition under Australian law as it gives ‘false credibility’, watchdog says
Australia’s national security laws watchdog has recommended removing religion from the legal definition of terrorism, arguing that the reference gives perpetrators false credibility and can stigmatise religious minorities. The proposal comes amid warnings that violent nationalism and other forms of extremism have made it harder to classify attacks by a single ideology.
The current federal definition covers acts intended to cause serious harm to people or property to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. The watchdog says religious motivation could instead be treated as part of a broader ideology category, and also recommends that making bomb threats should not carry life imprisonment. Muslim community groups welcomed the proposed change, while Australia’s peak Jewish body argued that religion can be an important part of how some terrorist acts are expressed.
In short
- Watchdog recommends removing religion from Australia’s terrorism definition.
- It says the current wording can stigmatise religious minorities.
- Jewish leaders question whether the proposed change reflects religious motives.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Removing religion as a separate category could avoid implying that faith itself lends authority to violence, while reducing the risk that the law stigmatises religious communities. Treating religious motives within a broader ideology category may also fit attacks shaped by overlapping or changing influences, rather than suggesting terrorism can be neatly assigned to one faith.
The case against
Keeping religion explicit could recognise that some attacks are genuinely framed and organised through religious beliefs, and that naming this motive may help describe them accurately. Folding it into a broad ideology category might obscure a relevant feature of those crimes or make the legal definition less clear to the public.
Explained simply
Australia’s federal law defines terrorism partly by the purpose behind an attack: it must aim to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. The definition applies to serious harm to people or property, and helps determine which acts are treated as terrorism under national security law.
The debate reflects the difficulty of describing attacks linked to overlapping beliefs, including violent nationalism and religious ideas. Muslim community groups and Australia’s peak Jewish body have taken different views on whether religion should remain explicit in the definition, amid concerns about how the law describes perpetrators and affects religious communities.