World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
DAILY MAIL COMMENT: The shame of Andy Burnham’s surrender to Brussels
The article argues that Andy Burnham is preparing to agree a closer relationship with the EU and bring it into UK law, despite the Brexit referendum result. It criticises the proposed deal as a political betrayal and says the government lacks a mandate for the move.
It claims the agreement could include cheaper university fees and full working rights for up to 100,000 EU nationals under 30, and cites Kemi Badenoch’s warning that it would deliver “the worst of both worlds”. The article also discusses uncertainty over approval for the Rosebank oil and gas project, and reports that at least 75 Labour MPs have written to the Prime Minister opposing it on energy-bill grounds.
In short
- The article condemns a proposed UK-EU reset deal.
- It says the deal could grant work rights to 100,000 young EU nationals.
- It also questions the government’s position on the Rosebank project.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of a closer EU relationship could argue that practical cooperation on mobility, education and trade would benefit people and businesses, while giving young people more opportunities. They might see updating UK law to support an agreement as a legitimate response to current needs, rather than a rejection of the referendum, provided the terms are transparent and receive proper parliamentary scrutiny.
The case against
Critics could argue that granting broad working rights or preferential university fees to EU nationals would materially change immigration and education policy, and that such changes should not be made without a clear electoral mandate. They may also see closer alignment with EU rules as limiting the UK’s ability to set its own policies, and argue that any agreement must be weighed against its costs and effects on public services.
Explained simply
Andy Burnham is the Labour mayor of Greater Manchester and a prominent figure in the party. The UK left the European Union after the 2016 referendum, and relations between the UK and EU have since been shaped by agreements covering trade and cooperation.
Closer ties can involve changes to rules on areas such as travel, work, education or trade. The debate matters because it raises questions about how far the UK should align with EU rules and who should approve such changes.
Rosebank is a large oil and gas field off the coast of Shetland. Decisions about developing it sit within wider debates over energy supply, climate policy and household bills.